September 24, 2016

September 23, 2016

September 22, 2016

Additional Insured Entitled to Coverage Where Accident Resulted from Named Insured’s Operations

A recent Indiana appellate decision illustrates that, for the purpose of triggering “additional insured” coverage, the insurer is liable where the injury arose out of the insured’s operations irrespective of whether the insured was alleged to be negligent. Peabody Energy Corp. v. Roark, 973 N.E.2d 636 (Ind. Ct. App. 2012).

The case involved a contract between Peabody, a mining company, and Beelman, a trucking company. Beelman’s employee, Roark, was making a delivery to Peabody’s mine when he was injured. Roark had parked his truck at the Peabody mine and was walking alongside it when the ground beneath him gave way, injuring him. Roark sued Peabody.

Peabody and Beelman’s contract required Beelman to indemnify Peabody against liability and to acquire insurance in order to do so. Beelman had acquired a commercial general liability insurance policy with insurer North American. However, the policy listed Peabody as an “additional insured” only for liability arising out of Beelman’s operations or premises owned or rented by Beelman. Thus, the question was whether Roark’s injury arose out of Beelman’s operations.

The trial court ruled that Roark’s injury did not arise out of Beelman’s operations. The appellate court reversed, finding that the injury did arise out of Beelman’s operations. The court held that Roark’s injury was directly related to his work as a truck driver for Beelman. North American had argued that Roark’s injuries were the result of Peabody’s sole negligence, not Beelman’s negligence, but the court rejected this argument. Because Roark’s injuries arose out of Beelman’s operations, Peabody was an additional insured under the North American policy.

© 2016 Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg LLP.

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg LLP is a Chicago-based law firm whose lawyers share a culture of teamwork and devotion to personalized client service to advance clients’ business interests throughout the U.S. and beyond. Our lawyers provide legal business solutions to public and private entities of all types in connection with domestic and global business transactions and litigation. Our client base reflects a number of Fortune 100 companies, financial institutions, nonprofits and high net worth individuals.

(312) 269-8000