August 27, 2014
August 26, 2014
August 25, 2014
Amazon Loses Gift Patent in European Patent Office "EPO" Opposition
In an EPO (European Patent Office) opposition proceeding, Amazon lost a patent on a gift giving feature on its e-commerce site. At the link below you can view and obtain a copy of the decision – Section 4 is of most interest. This is an example of how the “technical solution to a technical problem” test can be applied to essentially ignore claimed subject matter that, in the EPO’s view, is non-technical in nature, and then considering what remains in view of the prior art. Here it looks like the “invention” was only left with email after the non-technical subject matter was removed. Email, having been around for a long time prior to Amazon’s filing, was then considered in the prior art and the invention therefore being obvious.
Thanks to Stefan Danner and Jim Hallenbeck for reporting on this.
<span class="advertise"> Advertisement </span>
- Neither Data Structures Nor Gathering and Combining Data Are Subject-Matter Eligible
- China Grants First Patents to Graphical User Interface Designs
- eBay Enterprise, Inc. and eBay Inc. v. Lawrence B. Lockwood: Order Regarding Request to Expunge CBM2014-00025
- Callidus Software v. Versata Software and Versata Development Group: Denying Request for Additional Pages CBM2013-00052, 53, 54
- Netflix, Inc. v. OpenTV, Inc.: Decision on Rehearing of Institution IPR2014-00274
- Google, the House of Lords and the timing of the EU Data Protection Regulation