December 18, 2014
December 17, 2014
December 16, 2014
Wyndham Motion Puts the FTC on the Defensive
Wyndham Hotel & Resorts LLC (“Wyndham”) has filed a Motion to Dismiss the Federal Trade Commission’s (the “FTC”) Complaint against it, which alleges that Wyndham committed unfair and deceptive acts related to three data security breaches that Wyndham has suffered since 2008. More information about the FTC’s Complaint can be seen in an earlier blog post here.
As an example, Wyndham lists various statutes that grant the FTC explicit authority to regulate data security standards in specific contexts:
- The Fair Credit Reporting Act – imposes requirements for the collection, disclosure, and disposal of data collected by consumer reporting agencies;
- The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act – mandates data-security requirements for financial institutions; and
- The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act – requires websites to establish and maintain reasonable procedures to protect the confidentiality and security of information gathered from children.
Wyndham asserts that the FTC’s authority to regulate data security standards is limited to specific circumstances, and that Section 5 of the FTC Act does not provide the FTC with the broad authority upon which it relied in bringing its enforcement action against Wyndham.
As further support for its claim, Wyndham cites the FTC’s Report to Congress in 2000 (the “Report”). In the Report, the FTC admitted that it “lacks authority to require firms to adopt information practice policies or to abide by the fair information practice principles on their Web sites, or portions of their Web sites, not directed to children.” What’s more, in the Report, the FTC asked Congress to enact broader legislation requiring websites to “take reasonable steps to protect the security of the information they collect from consumers” and “provide an implementing agency with the authority to promulgate more detailed standards pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act.”
The implications of Wyndham’s Motion are far-reaching. Indeed, if the court finds for Wyndham and dismisses the FTC’s enforcement action, the FTC will likely have a tough road ahead when attempting to settle future claims with companies that have suffered from data breaches as a result of inadequate data security standards. Such a ruling for Wyndham could potentially provide enough ammunition to prompt Congress to step in and grant the FTC the authority that it requested over a decade ago in the Report. Wyndham’s Motion brings to light a possible gap in the FTC’s authority to regulate data security standards, despite all of the settlements that the FTC has made with companies on the basis of that authority.
This is an argument worth watching. Stay tuned.
- Implementing a Counterfeit Enforcement Program [VIDEO]
- Either Way You Say it, It’s Unauthorized: Mass. Federal District Court Declines to Dismiss Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) Claim
- Employees Who Download Trade Secrets As They Head Out the Door Can Be Guilty of TS Theft, Even Before They Make Use of the Information