September 3, 2015

September 03, 2015

September 02, 2015

September 01, 2015

A Zinger to IRS: Revisiting Artistes And Sportsmen Treaty Provisions

The recent Tax Court case of Garcia v. Commissioner,1 which dealt with the taxation of a nonresident alien (NRA) golfer’s endorsement income, has drawn much attention. Although the Tax Court increased the taxpayer’s U.S. federal income tax liability over what he had reported on his return, the decision has nonetheless dealt a devastating blow to the IRS’s aggressive rulings and litigating position on the scope of the ‘‘Artistes and Sportsmen’’ article2 of the income tax treaties to which the United States is a party.

This report focuses on two key aspects of Garcia: (1) the classification of an athlete’s endorsement income as royalty income rather than services income; and (2) the taxability of that royalty income under an ‘‘Artistes and Sportsmen’’ treaty provision. It does not address the method for allocating an athlete’s endorsement income between services income and royalty income, which was another issue in Garcia.

This report summarizes the U.S. federal income taxation of NRA athletes before turning to the relevant portions of Garcia. It argues that while the Tax Court’s stated rationale for rejecting the IRS’s position is undoubtedly correct, there is a more fundamental structural reason for why the IRS’s position is untenable.

Click the View Media link to read the full article.

©2015 Greenberg Traurig, LLP. All rights reserved.


About this Author

Seth J Entin, Tax Attorney, Greenberg Traurig Law FIrm

Seth J. Entin concentrates his practice in the area of federal income taxation, with an emphasis on international taxation. Seth has been listed in the Best Lawyers in America, Chambers Global, Chambers USA: America's Leading Lawyers for Business, Chambers and Partners Latin America, The Legal 500 US and Super Lawyers, and is an Adjunct Professor of International Taxation at the University of Miami School of Law. Seth speaks regularly at national and international tax conferences and is the Director for International Tax for the Florida Bar Tax Section.