May 30, 2020

May 29, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

May 28, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

May 27, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Consumer Product Safety Commission Begins Transition: Ann Marie Buerkle is Now the Acting Chairman of the Agency

This morning it was announced internally at the CPSC that Commissioner Ann Marie Buerkle has become the Acting Chairman of the agency. The CPSC has not yet released a statement concerning the transition of the chairmanship from Elliot Kaye to Ann Marie Buerkle, but we have confirmed the change in leadership with multiple sources inside the agency. In a move largely seen as a precursor to this change in leadership, the Commission recently voted to install Buerkle as the Vice Chairman of the agency — ensuring that she would become the Acting Chairman of the agency once Kaye vacated the Chairman’s office.

Kaye is no longer the Chairman of the agency but will remain on the Commission because his term as a Commissioner runs until 2020 regardless of whether he retains his status as the Chairman. The terms of every Commissioner are seven year fixed terms that are independent of the Presidency.

Given the terms of current slate of Commissioners, this means that the agency will not transition to a Republican majority and that Chairman Buerkle will preside as a minority Chairman. Absent the early resignation of a current Democratic Commissioner, the earliest that a new Republican Commissioner can assume a position on the Commission is in late October of this year when Democratic Commissioner Marti Robinson’s term expires.

Given this situation, we do not expect to see immediate and substantial changes at the CPSC similar to those currently occurring in other parts of the federal government. That said, the Chairman of the CPSC is afforded significant authority to direct staff resources and priorities so changes in accordance with Chairman Buerkle’s priorities likely will occur.

Specifically, the Consumer Product Safety Act states:

The Chairman of the Commission shall be the principal executive officer of the Commission, and shall exercise all of the executive and administrative functions of the Commission, including functions of the Commission with respect to: (A) the appointment and supervision of personnel employed under the Commission, (B) the distribution of business among personnel appointed and supervised by the Chairman and among administrative units of the Commission, and (C) the use and expenditure of funds.

In carrying out any of functions under the provisions of this subsection the Chairman shall be governed by general policies of the Commission and by such regulatory decisions, findings, and determinations as the Commission may by law be authorized to make.

Although a majority of the Commission could attempt to overrule the Chairman on issues within the Chairman’s inherent authority, that is only possible by stripping away the Chairman’s authority by creating a “general policy” of the Commission as allowed under the Consumer Product Safety Act. The Commission has been reluctant to do this throughout the history of the agency because both political parties usually favor a strong Chairman when they are in power.

Chairman Buerkle and fellow Republican Commissioner Joe Mohorovic have been vocal critics of the CPSC’s recent trend of significantly increased civil penalties. While civil penalties that are already in the pipeline and currently being negotiated by staff may still settle and be approved by the current Democratic majority for significant amounts, there may be eventually be changes in the way the agency approaches civil penalties.

Chairman Buerkle’s name has been circulating for some time now as a potential candidate for the permanent Chairman of the CPSC given her extensive experience inside the agency (and as a member of Congress) as well as the significant amount of proactive outreach she has done with agency stakeholders during her term as a Commissioner. Given the fact that a new Chairman from outside of the current Commission could not join the agency until late October at the earliest, it has also been pointed out that President Trump’s nomination of Buerkle as the permanent Chairman will allow for earlier hiring for key staff positions and the advancement and framing of her priorities as the Republican Chairman that can then be more quickly implemented once a third Republican Commissioner joins the agency.

©1994-2020 Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo, P.C. All Rights Reserved.


About this Author

Matthew Howarse, Consumer Safety, Attorney, Mintz Levin, Law Firm

Matt is a prominent consumer product safety lawyer who advises manufacturers, retailers, importers, distributors, trade associations, and test laboratories. He has extensive experience with compliance, regulatory enforcement, recalls, and other product safety related issues. He represents clients before the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), Health Canada, the Federal Trade Commission, Congress, and state agencies. Matt draws on his four-year tenure as the CPSC chief of staff and his many years advising clients in private practice to devise practical and...

Charles Samuels Antitrust Attorney Mintz Levin Law Firm

Chuck is an antitrust and regulatory lawyer who devotes a significant portion of his practice to assisting clients with consumer product safety and environmental regulations. He serves as general counsel to numerous trade associations. For the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers, Chuck negotiated and drafted amendments to federal laws, including the Consumer Product Safety Act. Corporations in many industries, local governments, and state agencies are also on his client roster. He represents clients before a wide array of federal agencies, including the Consumer Product Safety Commission, state agencies, and international regulatory organizations.

Chuck is engaged in a federal and international regulatory and legislative practice. He has been extensively involved in product safety, environmental, tax, health care, technology, and energy issues, and public finance legislative and regulatory matters for a variety of trade associations, corporations, local governments, and state agencies.

His practice encompasses work before the US Consumer Product Safety Commission, Departments of State, Health and Human Services, Energy, and Treasury, US Trade Representative, Environmental Protection Agency, Federal Trade Commission, the IRS, and other federal and state agencies. He also has extensive experience dealing with Canada, the European Commission, and international bodies.

Chuck also engages in trade association representation and antitrust counseling. As general counsel of the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers, Chuck negotiated and drafted the amendments to the Consumer Product Safety Act and the National Appliance Energy Conservation Act, and represents the appliance industry at international bodies dealing with safety, energy, ozone depletion, and global warming.