February 1, 2023

Volume XIII, Number 32

Advertisement

January 31, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

January 30, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

Italian Stock Exchange Authority (Consob) Issues Opinion on List Presented by Outgoing Board of Directors of Public Companies

An outgoing board of directors (BoD) must ensure that the creation of its own list for the appointment of a new board is transparent and documented, pursuant to the Italian Stock Exchange Authority (Consob) opinion dated Jan. 21, 2022.

Although not expressly governed by Italian Law1 and despite a lack of guidance in case law, the articles of association of several Italian listed companies allow the outgoing BoD to present its own list for the appointment of the new board members provided that the right of minority shareholders to appoint board members is not impeded or altered.

The presentation of a list by the outgoing BoD seems consistent with a BoD’s self-assessment process as set forth by Borsa Italiana’s Corporate Governance Code, and it could be the solution to the problem related to the lack of representativeness of the lists submitted by shareholders in companies where a majority shareholder who can direct the decisions of the shareholders meeting is absent.

The debate surrounding the conditions for the legitimacy of a list submitted by an outgoing BoD has become, especially in recent months, quite lively and interesting.

In addition to the transparency and documentability that the outgoing BoD must ensure in the creation of the list, Consob also highlighted the following key aspects:

  1. the need for adequate BoD meeting minutes regarding discussions and presentation of the list;

  2. the involvement of independent BoD members, the appointments committee, and, where possible, the BoD chair;

  3. transparency throughout all shareholder interactions;

  4. the obligation of transparency2 of each director available for reappointment, to avoid potential conflicts of interest;

  5. the need for timely publication and “correct and complete information on the list submitted by the Board of Directors and the procedures for its formation”;

  6. the need for a declaration on the absence of any connection with the list proposed by the BoD by the shareholders submitting another list;

  7. the circumstances under which directors are elected based on a list of candidates submitted by the BoD does not preclude the qualification of a shareholder as a related party.3

A few days after Consob issued its opinion, the Committee of Market Operators and Investors (COMI) issued its own opinion fully endorsing the need for mechanisms to safeguard transparency in selection of candidates for the list.

Ultimately, both COMI and Consob agree with the legitimacy of the list submitted by a BoD and on the need to reinforce best practices related to the selection and presentation of such list until legislative action definitively clarifies certain aspects that remain controversial.


1 See Article 147-ter of Legislative Decree 58/1998 (the so-called “TUF”), on the election and composition of BoDs of listed companies.

2 See Article 2391 c.c. of Italian Civil Code, on the interests of directors.

3 In fact, if a shareholder had representation on the BoD (directly or indirectly, for example, through corporate officers of companies belonging to his Group), this circumstance would have to be taken into account even if the said directors had been drawn from the list submitted by the BoD and not from the list submitted by the shareholders themselves.

©2023 Greenberg Traurig, LLP. All rights reserved. National Law Review, Volume XII, Number 66
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Carlo Scaglioni Partner Milan
Partner

Carlo Scaglioni focuses his practice on mergers and acquisition, joint ventures, and commercial contracts. Carlo represents Italian and foreign companies in the pharmaceutical, automotive, banking, and insurance sectors in both domestic and cross-border transactions as well as in drafting and negotiating commercial contracts.

Concentrations

  • M&A
  • Private equity
  • Cross border transactions
  • Joint ventures
  • Pharmaceutical, medical devices and health care
  • Commercial and distribution agreements
39-02-77197214
Abram Farina Corporate Law Trainee Greenberg Traurig Italy
Trainee

After completing his academic path, Abram joined Greenberg Traurig’s Corporate Department in November 2021, focusing on Corporate Law, M&A and Bankruptcy Law. He regularly supports the professionals of the firm in carrying out ancillary activities related to corporate acquisitions, corporate governance matters, and debt restructuring transactions.

Concentrations

  • Corporate

  • M&A

  • ...
39-02-771971
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement