August 10, 2022

Volume XII, Number 222

Advertisement
Advertisement

August 09, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

August 08, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Patent Exhaustion for Self-Replicating Articles

Tony Dutra’s article in Bloomberg BNA, “Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Patent Exhaustion for Self-Replicating Articles”, alerts us to some fascinating issues.  Mr. Dutra summarizes, “Self-replicating seeds set the stage for a conflict at the Supreme Court between two broad patent policies – the right of the patentee to prevent unauthorized making of patented articles and the right of a purchaser of a patented article to be free of restrictions on its downstream sale or use.”  Why are these policies apparently in conflict?  Well, seeds are self-replicating.  A genetically modified seed, patented by Monsanto Co., is capable of being planted and producing more seeds which contain the same genetic modification.  So, if a farmer plants these genetically modified seeds and the plants then produce more seeds, are the new seeds a “newly infringing article”?  Does the doctrine of patent exhaustion apply to the first sale of the seed, in which case a purchaser of the seed is free to use the seed as he sees fit?  Might a judicial exception be needed in the case of self-replicating articles?  Mr. Dutra reports that the justices heard arguments comparing aspects of the case to Microsoft’s “golden master” disk, which was used to install Windows onto foreign-assembled computers.  According to Mr. Dutra, the court said “the individual copies would be infringing if made in the United States”, although such was not applicable to the specifics at the time.  What intrigues me is the possibility that a ruling on this might be applicable to self-replicating structures in nanotechnology, to robotics that manufacture other robots, to 3-D printing machines, and to computers and databases.

Copyright © 2022 Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.National Law Review, Volume III, Number 90
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Christopher M. Hall, Womble Carlyle Law Firm, patent agent
Patent Agent

Chris Hall counsels clients in preparing and prosecuting patents in the electrical, telecommunications, computer software, and mechanical arts. 

Specifically, Chris has handled patents for:

  • Semiconductor processing, fabrication and integrated circuitry,
  • Optics
  • Optoelectronics
  • Artificial intelligence
  • 3-D imaging and image generation
  • Fault tolerance
  • Robotics

*Chris Hall is a registered patent agent and is not licensed to practice law. His activities are directly supervised by members...

408-341-3051
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement