July 24, 2014

Insurer’s Silence Does Not Evidence Consent For Purposes of Voluntary Payments Condition

In West Bend Mutual Insurance Co. v. Arbor Homes LLC, No. 12-2274 (7th Cir. Jan 8, 2013), the Seventh Circuit reaffirmed the critical importance of obtaining an insurer’s consent before settling a case.

The coverage action arose out of what Judge Rovner humorously characterized as “the biggest mistake a plumber can make:  he forgot to connect the home’s drainage system to the city’s sewer.”  As a consequence of that fatal error, the aggrieved homeowners demanded that the homebuilder furnish them with a new home.  Since the homebuilder was an additional insured on the plumber’s policy, the homebuilder requested that the plumber place its insurer on notice of the homeowners’ potential claims.  Meanwhile, the homebuilder negotiated a settlement, which it believed the plumber communicated to its insurer.  Hearing nothing from the insurer in response, the homebuilder mistook the insurer’s silence for acquiescence to the terms of the settlement.  In reality, the insurer never consented to the settlement and subsequently denied coverage under the voluntary payments condition in the policy.

The Seventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of coverage based on the homebuilder’s failure to obtain the insurer’s consent before settling.  While the court credited the homebuilder for behaving “very admirably in addressing the problem for the new homeowners,” it ultimately concluded that the homebuilder “failed to protect its own interests.”  The court emphasized that the voluntary payments provision was “not a notice provision, per se, but a consent provision,” and because the insurer did not assent to the terms of the settlement, the insurer was entitled to deny coverage.

© 2014 Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg LLP.

About the Author


Andrew G. May is an associate in Neal Gerber Eisenberg’s Litigation Practice Group and its Insurance Policyholder Practice Group. Andrew takes a results-oriented approach to clients’ needs and delivers dynamic and efficient solutions to complex legal problems. Andrew’s practice encompasses a wide array of litigation matters, including breach of contract disputes, defamation, common law and consumer fraud claims, insurance coverage, products liability defense and class actions.

Andrew sits on the Board of Directors for the Evening Associates of the Art Institute of...

(312) 827-147

Boost: AJAX core statistics

Legal Disclaimer

You are responsible for reading, understanding and agreeing to the National Law Review's (NLR’s) and the National Law Forum LLC's  Terms of Use and Privacy Policy before using the National Law Review website. The National Law Review is a free to use, no-log in database of legal and business articles. The content and links on are intended for general information purposes only. Any legal analysis, legislative updates or other content and links should not be construed as legal or professional advice or a substitute for such advice. No attorney-client or confidential relationship is formed by the transmission of information between you and the National Law Review website or any of the law firms, attorneys or other professionals or organizations who include content on the National Law Review website. If you require legal or professional advice, kindly contact an attorney or other suitable professional advisor.  

Some states have laws and ethical rules regarding solicitation and advertisement practices by attorneys and/or other professionals. The National Law Review is not a law firm nor is  intended to be  a referral service for attorneys and/or other professionals. The NLR does not wish, nor does it intend, to solicit the business of anyone or to refer anyone to an attorney or other professional.  NLR does not answer legal questions nor will we refer you to an attorney or other professional if you request such information from us. 

Under certain state laws the following statements may be required on this website and we have included them in order to be in full compliance with these rules. The choice of a lawyer or other professional is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements. Attorney Advertising Notice: Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Statement in compliance with Texas Rules of Professional Conduct. Unless otherwise noted, attorneys are not certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, nor can NLR attest to the accuracy of any notation of Legal Specialization or other Professional Credentials.

The National Law Review - National Law Forum LLC 4700 Gilbert Ave. Suite 47 #230 Western Springs, IL 60558  Telephone  (708) 357-3317 If you would ike to contact us via email please click here.