October 01, 2014
September 30, 2014
September 29, 2014
Ole! The 6th Circuit Side-Steps the Noel Canning Challenge and Issues Pro-Employer Ruling on "Supervisor" Issue
Just before the Fourth of July, the 6th Circuit delivered a favorable ruling for employers while avoiding the quicksand of Noel Canning. In GGNSC Springfield LLC v. NLRB, No. 12-1529 (6th Cir. July 2, 2013), the Sixth Circuit reversed the Regional Director's decision and found that a number of Registered Nurses (RNs) were supervisors for purposes of the NLRA thereby relieving the employer of the obligation to collectively bargain with the RNs. The Court found that the RNs exercised sufficient independent judgment when issuing discipline to constitute supervisor status under the governing Kentucky River standard. The Court's full opinion and reasoning can be found here.
Notwithstanding the substantive determination, this decision is most significant for the procedural manuevering by the Court to avoid getting enmeshed in the Noel Canning controversy. First, the Court found that "[e]rrors regarding the appointments of officers under Article II are ‘nonjurisdictional." Thus, the Court found, because the employer’s challenge to the NLRB's authority is not jurisdictional, the Court is not compelled to consider it. Next, the Court held that it need not consider whether the employer forfeited its Noel Canning argument by not raising it initially on appeal because the Court was granting relief on "the basis of its non-constitutional challenge.”
This decision is instructive to employers for purposes of structuring the duties of supervisors and also a powerful reminder to raise the Noel Canning challenge from the outset of – and throughout – the litigation.
<span class="advertise"> Advertisement </span>
- Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals Says Beneficiary of Approved I-140 Has Standing to Challenge an I-140 Revocation
- Michigan Court of Appeals Dismisses Home Care Workers Lawsuit Against SEIU as MOOT After SEIU Voluntarily Pays Back Union Dues
- EEOC Sues Two Employers for Transgender Discrimination
- Federal Court Stops the EEOC’s Assault on CVS’s Severance Agreement
- ICE Increases its Enrollment in Mutual Agreement between Government and Employers (IMAGE) in Puerto Rico by 12.5% in One Day!
- Ninth Circuit Upholds Tribal Preference in Employment