Department of Justice Files Suit Against Santa Ysabel Tribe’s “Desert Rose Bingo” Site
On December 3, United States Department of Justice attorneys filed a complaint in federal court seeking to prevent the Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel, a federally recognized Indian tribe near San Diego, from continuing to operate an online bingo site by enjoining its acceptance of any electronic payments under the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (“UIGEA”). California Attorney General Kamala Harris had filed a similar suit in late November alleging that operation of the site violated the Tribe’s gaming compact with the state.
UIGEA prohibits electronic financial transactions in connection with “unlawful Internet gambling.” UIGEA’s definition of “unlawful Internet gambling” includes any wager placed using the Internet when that wager would be unlawful on the federal, state or tribal lands where the wager is initiated or received. The Department alleges that, because California law prohibits non-charitable bingo off tribal land, Desert Rose Bingo equates to unlawful Internet gambling and UIGEA prohibits any electronic financial transactions made in connection with the site.
Desert Rose Bingo is limited to California residents. Those visiting the site from outside California are greeted with a message inviting them to register for the future but that non-residents “will not be able to participate in our games until further notice.” This geo-location technology, ensuring players are within California, is meant to avoid the application of federal law prohibiting online gaming across state borders such as the Interstate Wire Act of 1961. The Wire Act imposes criminal penalties for the interstate and foreign transmission of wagers and wagering information using a “wire communication facility.”
Nevertheless, Indian tribes have been diligently preparing for this perceived threat to their brick-and-mortar casinos. Santa Ysabel’s Desert Rose Bingo demonstrates the tribal determination to be at the forefront of Internet gaming and maintain a seat at the table.
The Santa Ysabel Tribe rejects the allegations of the state and federal officials, and even launched an online poker site, privatetable.com, earlier this month, which, according to the site, allows “real money games and poker tournaments.” The Santa Ysabel Gaming Commission website states that by offering online poker and bingo, “the Tribe is exerting its sovereign right under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) to regulate and conduct Class II gaming from the tribe’s reservation.”
The Tribe’s position that it retains the sovereign right to conduct online poker and bingo echoes the opinion of many Indian tribes, and even some gaming regulators, that such “Class II” Internet gaming may be operated by Indian tribes free of state regulation under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988. Clearly the Department of Justice does not agree.