December 3, 2020

Volume X, Number 338

Advertisement

December 03, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

December 02, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

December 01, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

November 30, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

HHS Inspector General Issues Physician Compensation Medicare Fraud Alert

The Office of the Inspector General of the Department of Health and Human Services (“OIG”) issued a warning earlier this month to physicians. The OIG enforces healthcare laws including the Stark Law and Anti-Kickback statute. Federal law prohibits hospitals from offering anything of value in exchange for certain healthcare business. Physicians can be paid for their services but not for sending Medicare patients to hospitals.

In recent years, there have been many prosecutions of hospitals for violating anti-kickback rules. Long gone are the days when a hospital would reward doctors bringing in patients with a cash bonus. Now, the “kickbacks” or bribes are more concealed.

Compensation agreements between hospitals and doctors are always scrutinized carefully. On June 9th, the OIG issued a written fraud alert to warn hospitals and doctors of new schemes that they see as problematic. This is only the fourth time in five years that the OIG issued a written fraud alert.

According to the Department of Health and Human Services, doctors who enter into compensation arrangements such as medical directorships must ensure that those arrangements reflect fair market value for services actually provided. Even if a compensation package is otherwise legal, it can still violate the law if just one of its purposes is designed to compensate the physician for bringing in Medicaid or Medicare patients.

The written guidance specifically addresses “medical directorship” arrangements.  The OIG believes some doctors are being given titles and extra pay simply because they bring in more patients. To avoid violating the law, a doctor offered a directorship must actually perform the duties of a medical director and his or her compensation must be reasonable.

Also called into question are arrangements in which the hospital agrees to reimburse the physician for office staff expenses.

Many people believe that the definition of a kickback is limited to money.  Actually, the regulations extend to anything of value. Reimbursing staff expenses saves the doctor money. Therefore it is considered compensation.

Traditionally, prosecutions have been directed at hospitals. Recently, however, the OIG successfully challenged 12 physicians who had received medical directorships or were reimbursed for office staff. All 12 doctors settled.

Another word of caution, even if the hospital funnels the money through an affiliated entity instead of making the payment directly, the result will be the same.

Although not mentioned in the alert, we have seen recent prosecutions of hospitals that have tried to circumvent the anti-kickback rules by offering certain physicians teaching or research stipends. Again, unless the work is actually performed, the arrangement will likely fail.

The purpose of the anti-kickback law is to prevent overutilization of healthcare services, prevent corruption in medical decision making and stop unfair competition. By publishing the guidance, the department hopes to help physicians avoid big fines and possible criminal prosecution.

Doctors are a frequent target of kickback schemes because they decide what medications their patients receive, what specialists they see and to what hospitals they must go when inpatient care is needed.

Catching fraud has become easier as more and more healthcare workers discover the False Claims Act and become whistleblowers. That law allows a whistleblower with inside information to receive up to 30% of whatever the government receives from wrongdoers. We have seen a definite uptick in whistleblower cases brought by office staff of both hospitals and medical practices.

Lest you think the risk is small, last year the government paid $635 million to whistleblowers. Most of the claimants had filed Medicare fraud complaints. 

© Copyright 2020 Mahany LawNational Law Review, Volume V, Number 168
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Brian Mahany, Attorney, Mahany Law, Former Law Enforcement

Brian Mahany is an American lawyer and author who leads a Fraud Recovery, False Claims Act (Whistleblower), and Accounting & Legal Malpractice law firm with a national footprint. His journey from Louisiana police officer to lead plaintiff’s counsel and whistleblower attorney in multiple billion dollar cases reads like that of a John Grisham protagonist.

Attorney Brian Mahany typically represents fraud victims, sometimes one or at times groups of 200 or more, who were victimized in complex multi-state or international frauds and also...

414-704-6731
Advertisement
Advertisement