July 17, 2019

July 17, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 16, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 15, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

$5.875MM: Another Million-Member TCPA Class Settlement Meets with Approval

Another day, another 7 figure TCPA settlement.

Today’s settlement approval comes to us from the Eastern District of Michican where a local furniture store saw its 2016 telemarketing effort turn into a multi-million dollar windfall for call recipients. See Bowman v. Art Van Furniture, Case No. 17-11630, 2018 WL 6445389 (E.D. Mich. Dec. 10, 2018).

In Bowman the defendant had allegedly left a bunch of voicemails regarding a VIP party at their stores with prizes. Fun. But the messages were (allegedly) left using a pre-recorded voice and without consent. Not fun. Because the messages were promotional in nature, this was (allegedly) a pretty straightforward violation of the TCPA.

Art Van Furniture allegedly sent similar messages to about 1,150,000 folks who made up the settlement class. The settlement figure was $5,875,000.00–or about $5.10 a class member.

As one objector pointed out, the potential liability in this case–if the claims were proven–might exceed $575,000,000.00 so the recovery for the class was about 1% of the potential recovery. The Court was not bothered by this argument and whisked it away with a single line: “The Court agrees with Plaintiff that the recovery in this settlement is consistent with other TCPA class action settlements.” Bowman at *7. So there.

Notably the Bowman settlement is in line with similar settlements. But then again, so was the Snyder settlement that was unceremoniously rejected by the Court a few months back.  

Copyright © 2019 Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.


About this Author

Our interdisciplinary Communications, Technology and Media team is comprised of lawyers with extensive experience in telecommunications, broadband, cable, broadcast, spectrum matters, program distribution, tower and facilities deployment, and all facets of the Internet and the broadband-enabled, Internet-of-things technologies that drive our connected economy. Our team also includes experienced telecommunications litigators adept at translating complex technologies and regulations to juries, judges, and arbitrators.

As former chief legal...