May 9, 2021

Volume XI, Number 129

Advertisement

May 07, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Court Denies Motion to Dismiss Declaratory Judgment Action in Trademark Dispute Involving Alticor

In Alticor, Inc. v. Nutrisystem, Inc., Case No. 1:12-cv-256, Alticor (the parent company of Amway) filed a declaratory judgment action seeking a declaration that its use of the NUTRILITE mark does not infringe Defendants' alleged rights in the NUTRISYSTEM mark. Defendants moved to dismiss the suit for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, arguing that Alticor merely sought an "advisory opinion as to a hypothetical situation," such that there was no actual case or controversy. Judge Robert Holmes Bell disagreed.

To maintain a declaratory judgment action, the Court noted that there must be a "definite and concrete" dispute between parties having adverse legal interests. Whether a plaintiff has a "reasonable apprehension of suit" is a valid consideration for determining if there is an actual controversy.

Prompting Alticor's declaratory judgment suit was a letter it received from Defendants' attorney alleging that Alticor's use and registration of the NUTRILITE mark infringed Defendants' rights in the NUTRISYSTEM mark and demanding that Alticor refrain from using the mark. The Court found that Alticor could reasonably interpret this letter as a threat to bring a trademark infringement action. An "accusation of trademark infringement," the Court observed, is "the hallmark of an actual controversy." As such, the Court denied Defendants' motion to dismiss.

We will continue to monitor this case, including any decision relating to the underlying trademark infringement dispute.

Advertisement
© 2021 Varnum LLPNational Law Review, Volume II, Number 286
Advertisement
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Gary J. Mouw, Varnum, litigation lawyer
Partner

Gary’s practice is primarily focused on representing companies and individuals – in Michigan and across the country – in connection with government enforcement actions and white collar criminal defense. He has extensive experience conducting internal investigations in a wide range of matters, including antitrust claims, False Claims Act suits, and environmental matters. Gary has represented clients in investigations conducted by the United States Department of Justice, the United States Attorney’s Offices throughout the country, the United States Department of Defense,...

616-336-6424
Advertisement
Advertisement