November 24, 2020

Volume X, Number 329

Advertisement

November 24, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

November 23, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Dishing Out the Latest F&B Litigation Updates: Part 1

In the Third and Eleventh Circuits, Ascertainability Continues to be a Major Certification Hurdle

In Re: Tropicana Orange Juice Mktg. & Sales Practices Litig., No. 2:11-cv-07382, 2018 WL 497071 (D.N.J. Jan. 22, 2018)

The Skinny:  This is the latest food and beverage case from within the Third Circuit to solidify Carrera’s heightened ascertainability standard. The standard is particularly difficult to meet where the plaintiffs’ proposed plan for ascertaining the class cannot be credibly tied to information or documentation that is demonstrably (and not just theoretically) available.

The Meat and Potatoes: Plaintiffs brought claims against Tropicana for the alleged mislabeling and misbranding of Tropicana’s orange juice product, Tropicana Pure Premium (“TPP”). Plaintiffs alleged that Tropicana’s marketing of the product as “pure, natural and fresh from the grove” was false and deceptive because flavoring is allegedly added.

In addition to finding a lack of predominance, Judge William J. Martini of the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey denied class certification on ascertainability grounds. The Court rejected the plaintiffs’ expert’s proposal to create a computer program to identify class members based on retailer loyalty card numbers and information submitted by consumers.  The Court determined that the vast majority of relevant retailers lacked the ability to compile the very data plaintiffs’ expert claimed would be required.

In Re: Wasser v. All Market, Inc., No. 16-cv-21238, 2018 WL 5629906 (S.D. Fla. Sept. 26, 2018)

The Skinny:  The Eleventh Circuit also continues to apply a rigorous ascertainability standard.  Having retailer data is very important for establishing ascertainability when dealing with small ticket items for which consumers likely have not saved receipts.

The Meat and Potatoes: Judge Robert N. Scola of the U.S. District for the Southern District of Florida denied class certification in a consumer product deceptive advertising case brought against All Market Inc., the parent company of coconut water manufacturer Vita Coco.  Plaintiffs claimed that the slogan “born in brazil” on the Vita Coco container, led consumers to believe that Vita Coco is sourced only from Brazil, when in fact All Market sourced coconut water from Brazil and other Asian countries.

The court rejected the plaintiffs’ injunctive relief claim because they were not forced to continue purchasing the product and could not be deceived in the future. The Court also found the class was not ascertainabile because the Plaintiffs provided no third party sales data to indicate that self-identification would be a “manageable process” that would not result in “mini-trials.”

Read Part 2 and Part 3 and Part 4.

© 2020 Bilzin Sumberg Baena Price & Axelrod LLPNational Law Review, Volume IX, Number 107
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Lori Lustrin, Commercial Litigation Attorney, Bilzin Sumberg Law Firm
Partner

Lori is a general commercial litigator who focuses on complex class-action and plaintiff opt-out antitrust litigation in federal court. In addition to antitrust work, her class action experience includes defending clients in the consumer products, homebuilding, real estate investment, and food and beverage industries.

Lori has also taken an interest in the emerging area of healthcare antitrust litigation and she has authored several articles on the subject. In addition to her varied federal court work, Lori has substantial experience in complex business litigation...

305-350-2385
Melissa Pallet-Vasquez, Litigation Attorney, Bilzin Sumberg Law Firm
Partner

Melissa Pallett-Vasquez is a Partner in Bilzin Sumberg's Litigation Group. She handles complex commercial litigation matters, class actions and arbitrations, often on behalf of clients from Canada. Melissa represents clients in a number of areas including real estate-related contracts, partnership and joint venture agreements, defense of intentional tort claims, internal investigations and intellectual property litigation. Melissa has substantial courtroom experience, including numerous federal and state trials, as well as international and domestic arbitrations, and in...

305-350-2393
Advertisement
Advertisement