October 26, 2020

Volume X, Number 300

Advertisement

October 23, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Indefinite Covenants Within License Agreement May Not Be Enforceable

Where a software license agreement precluded the licensee from developing similar software for an undefined period of time, the license agreement inhibited “free trade” and was therefore unreasonable and unenforceable.  Triage Logic Management & Consulting, LLC v. Innovative Triage Services, LLC, 2020 NCBC 57 (J. Robinson).  As a result, the Business Court held the licensor could not maintain a claim for breach of this provision of the license agreement.

Plaintiff Triage Logic Management and Consulting, LLC (“TLMC”) developed a software platform (“System”) for call-in triage nurses to use to address a patient’s specific medical questions. The patient-specific characteristic of the System distinguished TLMC’s software from similar products. In 2011, TLMC agreed to license the System to Defendant Innovative Triage Services, LLC (“Innovative”).  Within the License Agreement, TLMC included various “Protective Covenants,” including a provision whereby Innovative agreed not to develop software similar to the System.  Although the License Agreement was apparently of limited duration, the Protective Covenants explicitly “survive[d] the end of the license term” with no specified end date.   Prior to the Spring of 2019, Innovative allegedly contracted with another company, PQC Tech, to create software similar to the System, allegedly providing PQC access to TLMC’s software packages in the process. PQC then created a software platform that competed with and had many similar features of TMLC’s System. In the Spring of 2019, TLMC terminated the License Agreement with Innovative and filed suit, alleging Innovative breached the License Agreement by, inter alia, developing a software similar to the System.  Innovative sought to dismiss this claim, contending that the Protective Covenant’s indefinite ban on developing a competing product was unreasonable and unenforceable.

The Business Court agreed.  Although it did not adopt Innovative’s effort to analogize this particular Protective Covenant with a non-compete in the employment context, the Business Court nonetheless followed Fourth Circuit precedent and found that the Protective Covenant’s total lack of any expiration date inhibited “free trade” in North Carolina and was therefore unreasonable and unenforceable as a matter of law.  As a result, no claim for breach of that particular provision could be maintained.

Based upon this decision, a business may want to ensure that any restrictive covenant in its license agreements has a sunset provision to ensure its enforceability.

Additional legal points from this decision:

  • A claim for breach of a software license agreement may likely be pre-empted by federal copyright laws unless the claim requires an “extra element” other than the acts of reproduction, performance, distribution or display. (Opinion, ¶¶28-30).
  •  In order to maintain a common law unfair competition claim, a complaint must allege the defendant to be a competitor whose actions deceived the public. (Id., ¶56-57).
Copyright © 2020 Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.National Law Review, Volume X, Number 256
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Phil Mohr Bankruptcy and Litigation Attorney Womble Bond Dickinson
Partner

Phil is a trial lawyer. Although he will search for creative legal and business solutions for his clients, his more than two decades of trial experience for both publicly traded and privately held companies in state and federal courts throughout the country have taught him that some cases simply have to be tried to verdict. Representing companies that have both been wronged and accused of wrongdoing, Phil has honed his trial skills in cases involving complex business litigation (including fraudulent transfer and equitable subordination cases in federal bankruptcy court)...

336.721.3577
Advertisement
Advertisement