October 28, 2020

Volume X, Number 302

Advertisement

October 27, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

October 26, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Managers May Be Entitled to Advancement of Legal Fees, Even If Accused of Wrongdoing

Where the operating agreement provides for indemnification and advancement of fees to a manager who becomes a party to any civil action “by reason of the fact that he was an authorized representative of the LLC,” the manager is entitled to have the LLC pay his legal fees as the litigation progresses.  Vanguard Pai Lung, LLC v. Moody, 2020 NCBC 56 (J. Conrad). Because the plain language of the operating agreement mandated the LLC advance the manager his legal fees, the Business Court required the LLC to pay the manager’s attorneys’ fees even though the lawsuit asserted allegations that the manager had embezzled from and breached fiduciary duties owed to the LLC.

Defendant William Moody (“Moody”) was president, CEO and a manager of Plaintiff Vanguard Pai Lung, LLC (“Company”) for nearly a decade. The Company filed suit against Moody, claiming he engaged in self-dealing and improper activities which caused significant harm to the Company, including embezzlement and breach of his fiduciary duties. Moody filed a counterclaim seeking, inter alia, indemnification and a holding that the Company must pay his (Moody’s) attorneys’ fees that he had and would incur in defending against the Company’s lawsuit. The Company refused, contending that its lawsuit did not satisfy the operating agreement’s requirement that he be a party to the litigation “by reason of the fact” that he was an authorized representative of the Company.

The Business Court disagreed. Recognizing that the Company’s own complaint accused Moody of “using his position” with the Company to commit the various bad acts, the Business Court held such accusations provided the requisite nexus between the lawsuit and Moody’s position with the Company to trigger the operating agreement’s requirement that the Company advance Moody his fees during the litigation. The Business Court held Moody need not first prove he is entitled to indemnification in order to receive the advancement, so long as he agrees to undertake to repay any fees advanced if he ultimately loses the case. The fact that the Company accused Moody of breach of his fiduciary duties or to have “unclean hands” did not alleviate its obligation to advance Moody his legal fees, as neither affirmative defense was a defense to a claim for advancement. Finally, the Business Court recognized the doctrine of advancement can be wide enough to include those fees incurred in prosecuting a claim for advancement and, because the Company’s operating agreement did not exclude such fees from those that were recoverable, the Company had to pay Moody his legal fees both in prosecuting his advancement counterclaim and his fees incurred in defending against the Company’s claims.

Based upon this decision, a business may want to review its operating agreement or its by-laws before pursuing a claim against a former officer or manager, to determine whether its claims are worth potentially paying the legal fees of all parties involved.

Copyright © 2020 Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.National Law Review, Volume X, Number 256
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Phil Mohr Bankruptcy and Litigation Attorney Womble Bond Dickinson
Partner

Phil is a trial lawyer. Although he will search for creative legal and business solutions for his clients, his more than two decades of trial experience for both publicly traded and privately held companies in state and federal courts throughout the country have taught him that some cases simply have to be tried to verdict. Representing companies that have both been wronged and accused of wrongdoing, Phil has honed his trial skills in cases involving complex business litigation (including fraudulent transfer and equitable subordination cases in federal bankruptcy court)...

336.721.3577
Advertisement
Advertisement