July 10, 2020

Volume X, Number 192

July 10, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 09, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 08, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 07, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Part Two: To Pay, or Not to Pay (Rent) – California Landlord-Tenant Regulations During COVID-19

In this two-part series we will explore the various state-wide and local regulations in place governing the landlord-tenant relationship in California as well as practical guidance for both parties. Following Part One, we will now review a few practical tips to be considered by both landlords and tenants. 

COVID-19 has flipped the landlord-tenant relationship on its head. Although evictions and recovering possession are off the table for now, landlords are eventually entitled to their full rent payments and are not necessarily left without remedy. Unless prohibited by a local moratorium, landlords can initiate unlawful detainer actions while the Judicial Council Order is in place. Courts, however, will not be able to issue a summons on the unlawful detainer complaint, which will delay service of the complaint (and the tenant’s time to answer). In addition, if tenants fail to repay owed rent by the new due dates spelled out in the applicable jurisdiction’s moratoria, landlords can bring breach of contract actions and seek damages. The key takeaways from these temporary eviction moratoria are that they are temporary, and they do not relieve tenants from their ultimate obligations to pay rent.

While landlords may have non-eviction options, it is important to remember that the landlord-tenant relationship is not one-sided. Landlords will need tenants to survive the COVID-19 crisis and beyond, and working together with tenants to explore creative and amenable payment options may be the best solution. The alternative is not only costly litigation or the loss of income from the landlord’s property, but the potential loss of a strong and long-term tenant.

 Here are a few strategies that commercial landlords and tenants can employ to power through these uncertain times.

  • First and foremost, landlords and tenants alike should review the applicable eviction moratoria in their jurisdictions. While most cities have adopted some form of moratoria, they vary in the levels of protection afforded to both landlords and tenants.
  • With government programs in place to assist struggling tenants, landlords should demand transparency as to whether their tenants received any benefits and whether they can use those proceeds to pay their rent. This is especially true in cities like Anaheim, where tenants are required to pay what they can afford.
  • Tenants and landlords can negotiate payment plans or agree to terminate the lease agreements early. In these negotiations, landlords should feel comfortable inquiring as to whether a tenant recovered any insurance proceeds due to business interruption or the like. Rent reductions can be conditioned on this information and insurance proceeds should be applied to rent.
  • More broadly, landlords should seek financially relevant information from the tenant and a clean estoppel statement confirming no landlord defaults (separately or in a lease amendment) as a precondition to any rent adjustment.
  • Lastly, landlords should not hesitate to condition any lease concession with a lease extension, personal guarantee, or security interest in the tenant’s assets. 
©1994-2020 Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo, P.C. All Rights Reserved.National Law Review, Volume X, Number 136

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Antony Nash Real Estate Litigation Attorney Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo San Francisco, CA
Member

Antony has a robust real estate litigation practice that also incorporates complex business matters. He handles a wide variety of real estate cases: foreclosure proceedings in and out of court, eminent domain matters, lender liability and financing cases, easement challenges, and lease disputes. Developers rely on his counsel and courtroom prowess amid disputes involving subcontractors, the development approval process, and many other types of matters. He also represents landlords, tenants, trustees and beneficiaries, public agencies, and homeowner associations.

Antony represents...

858.314.1084
Gabriel Schnitzler Healthcare & Real Estate Attorney Mintz
Member

Gabriel works with commercial real estate, health care, technology, and energy clients in the acquisition, leasing, sale, financing and development of office, multifamily, industrial and R&D properties.

In his free time, Gabriel enjoys fly fishing and is a devoted baseball fan.

415-432-6004
Associate

Alyssa’s practice focuses on commercial and construction litigation and land use permitting and litigation. She guides clients through all stages of the litigation process, from counseling them on pre-litigation issues to researching and drafting pleadings and motions, managing discovery, taking and defending depositions, preparing witnesses for deposition and trial, and through trial. In the construction law and land use side of her practice, she advises clients on pre-litigation claims related to public and private construction projects, including delay claims on public works projects,...

415.696.5429
Edward M. Fallas Litigation Attorney Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo San Diego, CA
Associate

Edward focuses on complex commercial litigation and advises clients in a wide range of industries through all stages of the litigation process. He has experience in conducting legal research and drafting memos, briefs, and motions. He was a Summer Associate at Mintz in 2018.

While attending law school, Edward served as a judicial extern for the Honorable Cynthia A. Bashant of the US District Court for the Southern District of California. He was also a law clerk in the Criminal Division and the Criminal Enterprises Section of the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern...

858.314.1580
Michael J. Godwin Securities & Financial Institution Litigation Attorney Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo San Diego, CA
Associate

Michael's practice focuses on complex commercial litigation, securities and financial institution litigation, off-shore asset investigations, cross-border enforcement of judgments and awards, and white collar defense.

Prior to joining Mintz, Michael clerked for the Honorable Andrew G. Schopler of the United States District Court for the Southern District of California. During law school, he was an editor of the San Diego Law Review and a CALI award recipient.

RELATED PRACTICES

  • Complex Commercial...
858.314.1512