February 8, 2023

Volume XIII, Number 39


February 08, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

February 07, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

February 06, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Telecom Alert—DoT Requests Hold on 5.9 GHz Proceeding; FCC Ruling on Duplicative ROW Fees; 2.5 GHz Tribal Priority Window; Cities Vote to Expand Broadband Options; Form 477 Data—Vol. XVII, Issue 46

DoT Requests Hold on 5.9 GHz Band Proceeding

Last week, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) submitted a letter to the FCC from the U.S. Department of Transportation’s general counsel (DoT) asking the Commission to pause its 5.9 GHz band proceeding (Vol. XVII, Issue 43) and reengage with the DoT and other stakeholders before moving forward.  In its letter, the DoT emphasized that the FCC’s reallocation is unworkable and undermines innovation in transportation safety, it undervalues the safety benefits of the band and underestimates the cost and disruption that will result, and that the FCC has chosen unproven technology (cellular vehicle-to-everything technology).  The Commission will consider its proposal at its Open Meeting on November 18.  

FCC Issues Ruling Preempting Duplicative ROW Fees

Last week, the FCC’s Wireline Competition Bureau issued a Declaratory Ruling preempting rights-of-way (“ROW”) fee requirements imposed by three Missouri cities.  The Ruling was issued in response to a Petition for preemption filed by Bluebird Network alleging that the duplicative nature of the ROW fees creates a barrier to entry in violation of Section 253 of the Telecommunications Act (47 U.S.C § 253).  Bluebird asserted that the cities’ ordinances required both the entity that owned the telecommunications facilities located within the ROW, such as dark fiber, and the entity that utilized those facilities to provide services, to pay ROW fees.  The FCC’s Ruling preempts the cities’ ordinances to the extent they allow the cities to effectively double charge for the same use of the public rights-of-way by the same facilities. The FCC made clear that the Ruling is expressly limited to the “unique” facts of the case.   

2.5 GHz Tribal Priority Window Applications

The FCC issued a Public Notice last week announcing that 57 more applications were accepted for filing as part of the Rural Tribal Priority Window for licenses of unassigned spectrum in the 2.5 GHz band (Vol. XVII, Issue 36).  If accepted for final approval, these Tribal applicants will receive licenses for exclusive use of up to 117.5 megahertz of 2.5 GHz spectrum to assist with serving their communities with broadband and other wireless services, including 5G.  Petitions to deny the applications must be filed by December 10, 2020, oppositions to petitions to deny must be filed by December 21, 2020, and replies to oppositions must be filed by December 29, 2020.  Last month, the Commission granted 154 Tribal licenses through this first-of-its-kind Rural Tribal Priority Window. 

Chicago, Denver Vote to Expand Broadband Options

Earlier this month, voters in Chicago and Denver voted to approve moving forward with exploring ways to expand broadband access in their respective cities.  In Chicago, nearly 90% of ballots cast voted yes to a non-binding referendum question asking if the city should ensure that all of its community areas have access to broadband internet.  In Denver, over 80% of voters cast ballots in favor of allowing the city to opt out of SB 152.  That state law prevents municipalities from building and managing their own broadband networks.  Since 2005, when SB 152 was first enacted, 140 communities have opted out.  

FCC Releases Form 477 Data on Broadband Deployment

The FCC issued a Public Notice last week announcing the release of updated data on fixed broadband deployment and mobile voice and broadband deployment as of December 31, 2019.  According to the data collected via Forms 477submitted by all broadband providers in the United States, the number of Americans living in areas without access to terrestrial fixed broadband with speeds of at least 25/3 Mbps fell to 14.5 million at the end of 2019, a 46% decrease from the end of 2016.  While the Form 477 data may accurately identify wholly unserved census blocks, the Form 477 data is regarded as an inadequate indicator of unserved locations within partially served census blocks. 

Co-authored by Wes Wright and Sean Stokes

© 2023 Keller and Heckman LLPNational Law Review, Volume X, Number 321

About this Author

Jim Baller Communications Attorney Keller & Heckman Washington, DC

James (Jim) Baller represents clients across the U.S. in a broad range of communications matters including high-capacity broadband network projects, public-private broadband partnerships, telecommunications, wireless facility siting, right-of-way management, pole and conduit attachments, and barriers to community broadband initiatives.

Jim was the founder and president of the U.S. Broadband Coalition, a diverse group of more than 160 communications service providers, high technology companies, labor unions, public interest and consumer groups, state and local government entities,...

C. Douglas Jarrett, Keller Heckman, telecommunications lawyer, procurement law

Douglas Jarrett joined Keller and Heckman in 1979. Mr. Jarrett specializes in telecommunications law, policy and procurement matters.

Mr. Jarrett is a recognized expert in representing enterprises in negotiating telecommunications services agreements with the major wireline and wireless carriers, domestically and globally.  He also advises enterprises on M2M services, cloud computing and IVR technology procurements. 

Mr. Jarrett represents technology companies in securing amendments to the FCC rules to enable the...

Gregory E. Kunkle, Keller Heckman, regulatory attorney, FCC lawyer

Gregory Kunkle joined Keller and Heckman in 2006. Mr. Kunkle practices in the area of telecommunications, with an emphasis on assisting corporate clients and trade associations with various legal and regulatory matters before the Federal Communications Commission.

Mr. Kunkle regularly counsels critical infrastructure companies, such as electric utilities, oil and gas companies, and railroads, public safety agencies, and commercial providers regarding FCC wireless licensing and compliance issues.  He assists clients in identifying and acquiring...

Casey Lide Communication Attorney Keller & Heckman Washington, DC

Casey Lide represents clients on a broad range of communications matters including telecommunications, cable television, broadband Internet access service, wireless communications, right-of-way management, pole and conduit attachments, and barriers to community broadband initiatives.

Casey counsels public- and private-sector clients on contract drafting and negotiation matters, including fiber optic IRUs and leases, easements, franchises, attachment agreements, ISP service agreements, interconnection and collocation agreements, strategic MoUs and others.   

He collaborates...

Thomas B. Magee, Keller Heckman, transactional counsel, litigation attorney, FCC law, safety violation lawyer

Thomas Magee joined Keller and Heckman in 2000. Mr. Magee provides regulatory, transactional and litigation counsel to investor-owned electric utilities, electric cooperatives and municipalities regarding pole attachments and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) licensing of private wireless telecommunications services.

Mr. Magee has helped to resolve dozens of pole attachment disputes affecting make-ready costs, safety violations, unauthorized attachments, annual rental rates and other terms and conditions of access. He negotiates,...