August 4, 2020

Volume X, Number 217

August 03, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

U.S. Court of Appeals Decision Highlights Importance of Carefully Drafting Release Agreements

In Zuber v. Boscov’s, the Third Circuit narrowly interpreted a release agreement to permit the plaintiff to pursue a claim under the FMLA for interference and wrongful termination.  The employer moved to dismiss on the basis that his claims were barred by a previously-entered Compromise and Release Agreement (“C&R”) settling his workers’ compensation claim.  The C&R provided that it constituted a “full and final resolution of all aspects of the 8/12/2014 alleged work injury claim” and that the:

“employee is forever relinquishing any and all rights to seek any and all past, present and/or future benefits, including, but not limited to, wage loss benefits, specific loss benefits, disfigurement benefits, medical benefits or any other monies of any kind including, but not limited to, interest, costs, attorney’s fees and/or penalties for or in connection with the alleged 8/12/2014 work injury claim as well as any other work injury claim(s) Employee may have with or against Employer up through and including 4/7/2015.”

The District Court granted the employer’s motion to dismiss holding the language contained in the C&R was broad enough to encompass the FMLA claims.  However, the Third Circuit reversed, finding that the “C&R is unambiguously a specific and limited release rather than a general release,” that was only intended to release future workers’ compensation claims. 

The Third Circuit’s decision was limited to the specific agreement at issue, and the Court only discussed its effect on the employee’s FMLA and common law claims.  Nevertheless, releases should be drafted carefully to be as comprehensive as legally possible. 

Jackson Lewis P.C. © 2020National Law Review, Volume VII, Number 277

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Allison E. Maue, Jackson Lewis, Lawyer, agency proceedings, mediations, arbitrations attorney
Of Counsel

Allison E. Maue is Of Counsel in the Long Island, New York, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She has over fourteen years of experience litigating and advising clients with respect to a variety of labor and employment matters. In addition to acting as lead counsel in all aspects of court and agency proceedings, mediations, and arbitrations, Ms. Maue advises clients regarding the development and implementation of effective employment policies, handbooks, procedures, and contracts. Ms. Maue has prepared and presented training programs on investigations, harassment, and non-discrimination, and has...

631-247-4670