October 25, 2021

Volume XI, Number 298

Advertisement
Advertisement

October 25, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

Wisconsin Court of Appeals Concludes Watercraft Exclusion is Not Applicable Despite the Insured Contributing to Cost of the Watercraft Rental

Ottmann, et al. v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company, et al., Appeal No. 2009 AP 3245

On August 10, 2010, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals issued a decision in Ottmann, et al. v. American Family Mutual Ins. Co., et al., Appeal No. 2009 AP 2345 (“Ottmann”) in which the court held that despite the insured contributing to the rental fee of the watercraft, the watercraft exclusion in the homeowner's insurance policy did not bar coverage.

In Ottmann, one of the defendants, Rita Kulinski, rented a jet ski. Rita then asked her nephew, a 16 year old minor at the time, if he would like to operate the jet ski. While operating the jet ski, the jet ski collided with the plaintiff's jet ski resulting in the plaintiff's injuries. Despite the fact Rita's sister, Renee, (the insured and the minor’s mother) agreed to contribute $50.00 towards the rental of the jet ski the court nevertheless found that the watercraft exclusion did not bar coverage.

American Family issued a homeowners policy to Renee and her minor son. The watercraft exclusion in that policy stated Watercraft: We will not cover bodily injury or property damage arising out of the ownership, supervision, entrustment, maintenance, operation, use, loading or unloading of a watercraft (2) with inboard or inboard-outdrive motor power of more than 50 hp rented to any insured. In reversing the trial court's decision that the exclusion barred coverage, the court of appeals concluded that while it was obvious that the rental was a commercial transaction entered into for profit by Rita and the rental company, the court remained unconvinced that the minor's mother also rented it. The court stated we are not convinced that a reasonable insured would understand that by contributing to the cost of the jet-ski that was rented to another person... the insured could be said to have rented the jet-ski for herself. Because the court found that the jet-ski had not been rented to the insured, Renee, the court held the watercraft exclusion did not apply. Accordingly, the court reversed and remanded the trial court's decision for the trial court to reconsider the plaintiff's motion for declaratory judgment in light of the fact that the watercraft exclusion did not bar coverage. Judge Fine issued a dissenting opinion.

©2021 von Briesen & Roper, s.cNational Law Review, Volume , Number 232
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Heidi Vogt, von Briesen Roper Law Firm, Milwaukee, Insurance and Litigation Law Attorney

Heidi Vogt is a Shareholder and Co-Chair of the Litigation and Risk Management Practice Group as well as the Chair of the Insurance Coverage and Risk Management Section. Her practice focuses on insurance coverage litigation, commercial disputes, constitutional law, and complex litigation. She has represented insurance companies in Wisconsin and across the country in both state and federal courts in complex insurance coverage matters for more than 20 years.

She represents and counsels insurance clients on a wide variety of...

414-287-1258
Smitha Chintamaneni, Von Briesen Roper Law Firm, Milwaukee, Real Estate, Construction and Tax Law Attorney

Smitha Chintamaneni is a Shareholder and has represented businesses, governmental entities, and individuals in eminent domain, commercial real estate, leasing, taxation, and construction matters for over 15 years.

Notably, she acts as one of the attorneys for the Village of Mount Pleasant surrounding the Foxconn project, where she represents the Village on all eminent domain matters. Smitha also acts as outside counsel for several Wisconsin based corporations in their transactional real estate matters. She has also served as counsel for the Milwaukee County Zoo, as defense counsel...

414-287-1515
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement