January 19, 2019

January 18, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

January 17, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

January 16, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

11th Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Ex-NFL Coach's Defamation Action

A federal appeals court has ruled that a former Miami Dolphins coach—accused of bullying a player—did not have a valid defamation claim against a law firm that investigated the team's locker room culture.

The decision has significant implications for companies that engage in internal investigations. It also is the latest in an emerging line of cases dismissing public-figure defamation claims early when a plaintiff fails to plead a plausible claim of First Amendment "actual malice."

The Miami Dolphins had well-publicized locker room issues from 2012 through 2014 involving allegations of player bullying. These issues culminated in second-year lineman Jonathan Martin deciding to leave the team early in the 2013 season and seek psychiatric help.

Following intense media scrutiny, the Dolphins retained a law firm to conduct an internal investigation into its locker room culture. In a 144-page report, the firm found widespread bullying—including multiple instances of homophobic bullying—and singled out an assistant coach, James Turner.

Mr. Turner sued the law firm that prepared the report, Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, for defamation. A federal district court in Miami dismissed Turner's defamation claims against the law firm and the lead report author, Theodore Wells.

In affirming dismissal last month, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit held that the report's conclusions about Mr. Turner were protected opinions, as they were conclusions based on admittedly true facts stated in the report.

Significantly, the court held that Mr. Turner was a public figure who "chose to put himself in the public arena" by appearing in the 2012 season of Hard Knocks on HBO, engaging with the media following the law firm's report, and texting Mr. Martin to try to persuade him to make a public statement. In a ruling that adds helpful precedent for defending public figure defamation claims, the court further held that Mr. Turner failed to plead a plausible claim for First Amendment actual malice—that the law firm knew the statements were false or subjectively entertained doubts as to their truth—because he did not allege facts showing that the defendants "knowingly or with reckless disregard" published false statements. Instead, the court held, Mr. Turner attempted to base his malice claim on failure to include additional facts that were either contained in the report or were deemed immaterial, and on conclusory statements of malice that must be disregarded under federal pleading standards that require plaintiffs to state facts that plausibly support their claims.

Copyright © by Ballard Spahr LLP


About this Author

Charles Tobin, Ballard Spahr Law Firm, Entertainment Media Litigation Attorney

Charles D. Tobin is a litigator, former journalist, and the Co-Practice Leader of Ballard Spahr's Media and Entertainment Law Group. He defends the media in libel and privacy lawsuits in state and federal trial and appellate courts throughout the country. He conducts prepublication content review and advises clients on subpoenas, access and privilege issues, Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, copyright matters, and First Amendment rights.

Mr. Tobin also represents businesses in matters involving unfair competition, disparagement, and...

Daniel L. Delnero, Atlanta attorney,Ballard Spahr consumer financial services litigation

Daniel L. Delnero represents a range of companies and individuals in consumer financial services litigation. He advises clients in large, complex matters involving banking and finance, constitutional due process challenges, corporate fraud, and state law tort actions.

Before entering private practice, Mr. Delnero was a law clerk for Hon. Lisa Godbey Wood, Chief Judge of the Southern District of Georgia.


Recognition & Accomplishments

Named by Georgia Super Lawyers as a Rising Star (Business Litigation), 2016