May 24, 2020

May 22, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement Looks to Address Offshore Safety Component Failures at Upcoming Forum

Next week, the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (“BSEE”) will host a forum on critical offshore connector equipment failures, including connector bolts used in blowout preventers (“BOPs”) currently deployed on the U.S Outer Continental Shelf (“OCS”) and worldwide.  The forum follows a flurry of recent activity by BSEE to address potential safety and environmental risks associated with faulty subsea connector bolts.

To illustrate the importance of these seemingly basic BOP components, BSEE Director Brian Salerno, in a July 2016 “Director’s Corner” blog post, detailed two reported failures of connector bolts that have occurred over the past six years.  Director Salerno warned that “[w]ith so much at stake during these operations, we have a responsibility to the workers and the environment to make sure that every one of those bolts can handle the stresses they are designed to withstand.” Director Salerno’s post also outlined the steps that BSEE plans to take to address those failures, including: (1) utilizing information on safety component failures that will be reported under the “Blowout Preventer Systems and Well Control Rule” (“Well Control Rule”) to better understand the extent of the problem; (2) working with other domestic and international regulators to identify global bolt failure incidents and causes; and (3) reaching out to and coordinating with industry participants to determine ways to improve quality assurance, manufacturing specifications and proper installation and use of subsea bolts.

This client alert discusses BSEE’s review of prior reported connector bolt failures, outlines the new reporting requirements in BSEE’s Well Control Rule, and details safety component, supply chain, quality control, and contractor issues that oil and gas companies operating offshore should be mindful of going forward.

BSEE’s Review of Prior Connector Bolt Failures

BSEE’s current focus on connector bolt failures follows a series of incidents and investigations over the past few years, and indicates that the agency believes the issue to be a recurring and unresolved problem.  In July 2014, BSEE issued a report entitled “Evaluation of Connector and Bolt Failures,” in which it found that connector bolts had cracked due to quality control problems, in particular inadequate coating and treatment of the bolts.  BSEE also concluded that existing industry standards do not adequately address bolting/connector performance in subsea marine applications.

Since that time, problems with bolt connectors have continued, and in January 2016, Director Salerno sent a letter to the American Petroleum Institute (“API”) noting that two additional connector bolt failures had occurred since the incident that had originally prompted BSEE to issue the 2014 Report—including one incident that had occurred less than 30 days prior to the letter.  According to the Director, “[t]he fact that these failures involved equipment from the three primary manufacturers of this equipment suggests that this is a systematic industry problem that requires immediate attention.”

On February 2, 2016, a month after sending the API letter, BSEE issued a safety alert, encouraging offshore operators to work with original equipment manufacturers (“OEMs”) to: (1) verify that there is complete documentation demonstrating that all components currently in service satisfy the metallurgical properties specified by the OEM and the latest industry standards; (2) verify that all installation and maintenance procedures (including torque processes and values) satisfy OEM requirements and ensure that these practices are effectively implemented; and (3) report any failures to OEMs and appropriate industry organizations in a timely manner to ensure the prompt transmission of relevant data to the industry.

Following this safety alert, API and a number of other industry representatives engaged with BSEE to address the recommendations contained in the alert.  A March 2016 presentation noted that there had been a number of instances of failed bolting due to properties of the steel used, improper use (procedures, torque, etc.) and problems with the design of the bolting system.

Joint BSEE and industry collaboration on bolt connector problems has continued throughout 2016, and BSEE has collected materials related to this effort on its website, which is available here.  Further discussion and collaboration can be expected at the forum scheduled for August 29, 2016.

New Reporting Obligations

Effective July 28, 2016, section 250.730(b) of BSEE’s Well Control Rule requires an operator to provide written notice of an “equipment failure” to BSEE and the equipment manufacturer within 30 days after the “discovery and identification” of the failure.  In this context, “failure” is defined as “any condition that prevents the equipment from meeting the functional specification.”  Section 250.730(b) also mandates that an operator perform an “investigation and failure analysis” within 120 days of a failure to determine the cause of the failure.  Results of the investigation and corrective actions must be documented and, in specified instances, provided to BSEE.

Looking Forward – Addressing Supply Chain and Quality Control Concerns

In light of the new reporting obligations prescribed in the Well Control Rule and BSEE’s continuing focus on connector bolt failures, it is clear that companies operating on the OCS should work with their contractors and OEMs to evaluate potential problems in components used in safety critical equipment.  When there are incidents and/or testing failures of safety critical equipment planned to be or currently deployed on the OCS, companies should conduct an investigation into the reasons for those failures, both to remain in compliance with BSEE’s regulations and to determine whether further analysis of supply chain and/or quality control processes is warranted.

© 2020 Van Ness Feldman LLP


About this Author

Michael Farber, Van Ness Feldman Law Firm, Washington DC, Environmental, Cybersecurity and Litigation Law Attorney

Mike Farber has twenty years of experience, both as a partner in private practice and as a government official, in rapidly assessing, investigating, and resolving compliance issues across a wide variety of industries. Mike provides clients with strategic counsel on complex regulatory and oversight challenges in the oil and gas and related industries and defends clients in government investigations and litigation.

Prior to joining the firm, Mike served as the Senior Advisor to the Director of the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE) at the U.S....

Jonathan Simon, Van Ness Fledman Law Firm, Washington DC, Cybersecurity, Environmental and Litigation Law Attorney

Jonathan Simon represents clients before the courts, Congress, and federal agencies on a broad range of matters involving natural resources, public lands, environmental, and energy law.  Jon’s practice focuses on providing legal and strategic guidance and counsel with regard to the management and use of federal lands and the development of energy infrastructure projects.  Jon has broad experience in matters involving the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Endangered Species Act (ESA), Clean Water Act (CWA), Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA), Wilderness Act, and other environmental and natural resource-related statutes.  He also has specialized experience working with project developers, Alaska Native corporations, and others on resource development and land use issues in Alaska. 

Jon assists clients with NEPA strategy and compliance, and throughout the process of obtaining and defending special use permits, right-of-way grants, and other use authorizations needed to construct natural gas pipelines, electric transmission facilities, and other infrastructure projects on or across federal and state lands.  He has represented clients on various projects, large and small, including the Alaska natural gas pipeline.  In addition, Jon has represented clients on oil pipeline tariff and related matters arising under the Interstate Commerce Act.

R. Scott Nuzum, Van Ness Feldman Law Firm, Washington DC, Cybersecurity, Energy and Environmental Law Attorney

Scott Nuzum represents clients seeking to develop oil and gas resources on federal and tribal lands onshore and on the Outer Continental Shelf. Scott also advises clients on the planning and construction of energy infrastructure, including pipelines, transmission lines, and renewable energy facilities. Having worked in both the White House and the Interior Department, Scott has experience with a wide range of federal energy, natural resources, and environmental authorities. Scott understands that subtle differences in federal agency practice and interpretation can have...