April 9, 2020

April 08, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

April 07, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

April 06, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Excess Carrier Not Required To Defend Or Indemnify Insured When Sued By Late Wife’s Estate For Negligence In Operating Motor Vehicle

But Must Defend Third Party Contribution Claims By Medical Malpractice Defendants

The insured drove his vehicle into a tree severely injuring his wife who died a week later. The wife’s estate filed two suits, one against the insured for negligent driving and the other against a hospital and attending physicians alleging malpractice. State Farm had primary limits of $250,000 per person, and Cincinnati had excess coverage up to $5 million. The insured did not notify Cincinnati until 26 months after the accident, although the wife’s estate advised Cincinnati 16 months after the accident. Cincinnati sought a declaratory judgment that it was not obligated to defend the insured because he did not provide notice "as soon as practicable" following the accident. Also, as the wife was also uninsured, it claimed an exclusion for claims by an insured applied even though there was an exception where "a third party acquires a right of contribution." The trial court ruled in favor of the insured.

The Seventh Circuit determined that 16 months notice was not remotely "as soon as practicable." However, Cincinnati did not identify any prejudice, so the delay did not affect its duty to defend. It also held Cincinnati was not required to defend the direct action by the estate against the insured, but did have a duty to defend the third party contribution action filed by the malpractice defendants. Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Estate of Chee, 826 F.3d 433 (7th Cir. 2016).

© 2020 Heyl, Royster, Voelker & Allen, P.C


About this Author

Success in litigating insurance coverage issues hinges on understanding both the interpretation of insurance policies and the handling of claims. These key elements pervade every phase of the business from taking the application, through underwriting, and policy issuance. The members of our firm's insurance coverage practice group understand these elements and the important role they play in risk management.