May 20, 2019

May 20, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Fourth Circuit Expands Title IX Liability for Harassment Through Anonymous Online Posts

The Fourth Circuit recently held that universities could be liable for Title IX violations if they fail to adequately respond to harassment that occurs through anonymous-messaging apps.

The case, Feminist Majority Foundation v. Hurley, concerned messages sent through the now-defunct app Yik Yak to the individual plaintiffs, who were students at the University of Mary Washington. Yik Yak was a messaging app that allowed users to anonymously post to discussion threads. 

Because of the app’s location feature, which  allowed users to see posts within a 5 mile radius, the Court concluded that the University had substantial control over the context of the harassment because the threatening messages originated on or within the immediate vicinity of campus. Additionally, some of the posts at issue were posted using the University’s wireless network, and thus necessarily originated on campus.

The Court rejected the University’s argument that it was unable to control the harassers because the posts were anonymous. It held that the University could be liable if it never sought to discern whether it could identify the harassers.

The dissent encouraged the University to appeal the decision stating that “the majority’s novel and unsupported decision will have a profound effect, particularly on institutions of higher education . . .  Institutions, like the university, will be compelled to venture into an ethereal world of non-university forums at great cost and significant liability, in order to avoid the Catch-22 Title IX liability the majority now proclaims. The university should not hesitate to seek further review.”

Copyright © 2019 Robinson & Cole LLP. All rights reserved.

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Kathleen Dion, Robinson Cole Law Firm, Litigation Law Attorney, Hartford
Partner

Kathleen Dion, a member the firm's Litigation Section, focuses her practice on all aspects of civil and criminal litigation. She frequently handles cases related to education, government and internal investigations, and business disputes.

Education Law

Kate represents private schools, colleges, and universities in a variety of civil matters, such as tuition disputes, allegations of staff misconduct, and Title IX matters. She has assisted her clients in reaching favorable settlements in several employee...

860-275-8231