February 8, 2023

Volume XIII, Number 39

Advertisement

February 07, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

February 06, 2023

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Highland Capital Asks Supreme Court to Review Fifth Circuit Exculpation Excision Ruling

Last November we wrote about the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision in Highland Capital Management, L.P., where the court reversed the bankruptcy court’s approval of a plan’s exculpation clause for non-debtors and limited the universe of parties covered by that provision. Relying on Bank of New York Trust Co., NA v. Official Unsecured Creditors’ Comm. (In re Pacific Lumber Co.), 584 F.3d 229 (2009), the Fifth Circuit held that the plan’s exculpation provision was overly broad and violated section 524(e) of the Bankruptcy Code. 

Earlier this month the reorganized debtor filed a petition for a writ of certiorari, asking the Supreme Court to resolve what it characterized as an acknowledged and long-standing conflict among the Circuits concerning the effect and reach of section 524(e) of the Bankruptcy Code.  According to the reorganized debtor, the majority approach – followed by the Second, Third, Fourth, Sixth, Seventh, Ninth and Eleventh Circuits – holds that section 524(e) permits bankruptcy courts to confirm plans containing non-debtor exculpations or third-party releases.  In contrast, only two Circuits – the Fifth and Tenth – hold that section 524(e) prohibits confirmation of plan that exculpates or releases non-debtors.  The reorganized debtor argues that this disparity conflicts with the policy objective of uniformity and encourages forum shopping. 

Importantly, the reorganized debtor asked the Supreme Court to consider only whether section 524(e) prohibits non-debtor exculpations and did not ask the Court to consider whether non-debtor releases are permitted under section 524(e).  As acknowledged in the petition, non-debtor releases “raise a host” of questions beyond the reach of section 524(e), including, most notably, constitutional and jurisdictional issues.  We note that the decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in the Purdue Pharma case concerning the permissibility of third-party non-debtor releases — which has been pending since April 2022 — remains eagerly awaited.

We will continue to keep our readers informed on this very important case.

© Copyright 2023 Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLPNational Law Review, Volume XIII, Number 25
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Norman N. Kinel Restructuring & Insolvency Attorney Squire Patton Boggs New York, NY
Partner

Norman Kinel is a partner in the firm’s Restructuring & Insolvency Practice and the national chair of the firm’s Creditors’ Committee Group. With more than 30 years of experience as a bankruptcy practitioner, Norman has successfully represented and litigated on behalf of clients in some of the nation’s largest and most intricate bankruptcy cases, involving numerous industries. Norman’s clients value his responsiveness to their needs and his tenacity in pursuing dynamic strategies to protect and maximize their interests.

Norman regularly represents debtors, creditors, bondholders...

212-407-0130
Mark Salzberg, Restructuring, Insolvency, Bankruptcy, Attorney, Squire Patton Bo
Partner

Mark Salzberg is a partner in Squire Patton Boggs’ Washington, DC office and a member of the firm’s Restructuring & Insolvency practice group. He focuses his practice on bankruptcy litigation, creditors’ rights, debtor reorganizations and complex commercial litigation.

202 457 5242
Michelle Saney Restructuring and Insolvency Lawyer
Associate

Michelle Saney is an associate in the Restructuring & Insolvency Practice Group based in the New York office. Michelle joins the firm with a wealth of knowledge and experience through the US bankruptcy courts, specifically in the aviation, mortgage servicing, energy, agriculture and healthcare industries.

Prior to joining the firm, Michelle clerked for the Honorable James L. Garrity Jr. in the US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York, and for the Honorable Karen K. Specie in the US Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District...

212-872-9888
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement