July 16, 2020

Volume X, Number 198

July 16, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 15, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 14, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

July 13, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Indiana Mayor Cannot Remove Utility Superintendent

The Indiana Supreme Court recently ruled that the former mayor of the City of Lawrence, Indiana, lacked authority to unilaterally terminate the city’s utility superintendent. The dispute, City of Lawrence Utils. Serv. Bd. v. Curry, arose in 2011 after the then newly elected mayor of Lawrence terminated the utility superintendent, citing differences in objectives for the city’s municipally-owned utilities.

In its analysis, the court initially noted that, while a utility service board generally has the authority to appoint and remove a utility superintendent under Ind. Code 8-1.5-3, such authority is “subject to” the mayor’s authority to appoint and remove a department head under Ind. Code 36-4-9 and 36-4-11. Id. at 2-8. The court then turned to those chapters and found that, in this case, the mayor’s statutory removal authority under Ind. Code 36-4-9-4 was not triggered because the city had not established a Department of Utilities or a department head position under Ind. Code 36-4-9-4(c)(7) Id. The court therefore determined that the utility superintendent’s termination fell under the statutory process contained in Ind. Code 8-1.5-3, where “the superintendent may [only] be removed by the [utility service board] for cause at any time after notice and hearing.”

In its conclusion, the court noted that its decision “may well offend sound public policy” but reiterated “that its job ‘is to interpret, not legislate, the statutes before [it].’”

© 2020 BARNES & THORNBURG LLPNational Law Review, Volume VII, Number 48


About this Author

The Governmental Services & Finance Department offers a full range of federal, state, and local government-related legal services to businesses and governments. The department includes lawyers from various practice areas creating a multidisciplinary team to meet the needs of our clients.

At times, clients need to capture the attention of government officials at both state and national levels through lobbying and public affairs efforts. Our bipartisan department serves our clients as lobbyists and public affairs advisors on a wide variety of business, government, and trade...