June 30, 2022

Volume XII, Number 181

Advertisement
Advertisement

June 29, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

June 28, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

June 27, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

Michigan Supreme Court to Provide Clarity on Alternative Apportionment of Income Tax for Out-of-State Companies

The Michigan Supreme Court has agreed to hear one of the most significant cases in the country to examine the question of when the Due Process and Commerce Clauses of the U.S. Constitution require the application of an alternative apportionment method, Vectren Infrastructure Services Corp. v. Department of Treasury.

The Court will consider whether the amount of tax the Michigan Department of Treasury assessed due to the sale of a company was so misaligned with the taxpayer's actual business structure that it led to "a grossly distorted result." A determination of a distorted result is significant because the Court then would need to consider whether the statutory formula (which resulted in such a distorted result) runs afoul of the Commerce Clause and Due Process Clause as applied to the taxpayer. Moreover, if the apportionment runs afoul of either constitutional clause, the Michigan Supreme Court will then consider the procedure for determining an alternative apportionment method. The Court's decision on the latter two issues could alter the way Michigan assesses taxes against businesses sold that have either minor operations or no permanent business locations in Michigan. 

The issues arose when the taxpayer, a Minnesota company with neither a permanent business location nor permanent employees in Michigan, sold its business in 2011. While the taxpayer did have a contract to provide oil spill cleanup services in Michigan when the company was sold, the Michigan Department of Treasury decided that roughly 70 percent of the taxpayer's business should be apportioned to Michigan for tax purposes.

After a prior remand from the Michigan Supreme Court, both the trial court and Court of Appeals concluded that the statutory method resulted in a constitutional violation. In response, the Michigan Department of Treasury sought leave to appeal, which resulted in this order.

Michigan taxpayers may have new options in apportioning their income to Michigan depending on how the Michigan Supreme Court decides these three issues:

  1. whether apportionment is distorted in the present case,

  2. whether a distorted apportionment runs afoul of the Commerce and the Due Processes clauses, and

  3. whether the taxpayer must petition in advance for alternative apportionment where the statutory apportionment runs afoul of constitutional clauses.

Out-of-state employers with operations in Michigan will want to stay up to date on the developments of Vectren. 

© 2022 Miller, Canfield, Paddock and Stone PLC National Law Review, Volume XII, Number 90
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Christie R. Galinski Tax Lawyer Miller Canfield
Principal

Christie Galinski is a tax attorney with more than 12 years of sophisticated transactional experience providing research and analysis regarding federal, state and international tax issues.

Christie's practice has focused on transactional tax issues, such as investment funds (including RICs and REITs), international tax issues, state tax issues, FATCA, tax-exempt organizations, formation of entities, 1202 stock, mergers and acquisitions, the CARES Act and other COVID relief. She also has experience requesting private letter rulings and closing agreements with the Internal Revenue...

1.312.460.4268O
Gregory A. Nowak Attorney Tax Lawyer Miller Canfield
Senior Counsel

Gregory Nowak is one of Michigan's leading experts on state and local tax issues. With more than 20 years experience, he focuses his practice on both structural tax planning and state tax controversy matters. 

Throughout his career, he has represented many major companies on multistate tax matters including clients in the manufacturing, retail, and transportation industries. Greg has litigated and negotiated issues involving all of Michigan's major taxes and has played an active advisory role in most of the significant Michigan tax controversies in recent years. He served as a...

313-496-7963
Samuel Parks Attorney Tax Lawyer Miller Canfield
Associate

Samuel Parks is an associate in Miller Canfield's Corporate Group, with a focus on transactional and particularly tax work. He also has experience advising both public and private sector clients on employee benefit issues, including facilitating corrections of plan documentation and operational compliance failures, as well as drafting plan documentation and participant communications. A graduate of the University of Michigan Law School, he has previously worked at the Michigan Supreme Court and the Washtenaw Public Defender's Office. 

248-267-3361
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement