June 25, 2018

June 25, 2018

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

June 22, 2018

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Northwestern University Defeats 403(b) Lawsuit

A federal judge in the Northern District of Illinois recently dismissed a lawsuit against Northwestern University alleging that the University and its fiduciaries mismanaged its retirement and voluntary savings plans. This is the latest decision in a series of class action lawsuits against prominent universities in which plaintiffs allege fiduciary violations of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (ERISA) for retirement plans governed by Internal Revenue Code Section 403(b). Northwestern is the second university to obtain a complete victory on a motion to dismiss in a 403(b) university case; the first university to do so was the University of Pennsylvania in Sweda v. University of Pennsylvania.

In Divane v. Northwestern University et al., No. 16 C 8157 (N.D. Ill. May 25, 2018), plaintiffs alleged that Northwestern University and its fiduciaries breached fiduciary duties, engaged in prohibited transactions under ERISA and failed to monitor other fiduciaries. Specifically, fiduciaries allegedly mandated the inclusion of particular stock accounts in the plans, imposing excessive record-keeping fees, improperly allowed payment for record-keeping expenses through revenue sharing, and included too many investment options. The Court rejected all of plaintiffs’ fiduciary duty claims.

The Court also rejected plaintiffs’ claims that defendants engaged in prohibited transactions. Namely, the Court held that there was no transfer of plan assets that would substantiate a prohibited transaction claim under ERISA Section 1106(a)(1)(D) and similarly rejected plaintiffs’ Section 1106(a)(1)(C) argument that fiduciaries engaged in transactions that resulted in “furnishing of goods, services, or facilities between the plan and a party in interest” as a “circular “argument.

The Court denied plaintiffs’ motion for leave to amend, amounting in a complete victory for Northwestern.

© 2018 McDermott Will & Emery

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

J. Christian Nemeth, McDermott Will, business torts lawyer, aviation matters attorney
Partner

J. Christian (Chris) Nemeth provides legal counsel on complex commercial litigation, including contract disputes, shareholder derivative actions, financial and banking matters, business torts, aviation matters, insurance cases, white-collar criminal matters and health care litigation.

Chris represents clients in courts at the state and federal levels across the country, and has successfully tried cases involving a wide range of matters. He also arbitrates cases in domestic and international forums.

Chris has extensive...

312-984-3292
Joseph K. Urwitz, Employee Benefits Lawyer, McDermott Will Emery Law Firm
Associate

Joseph K. Urwitz is an associate in the law firm of McDermott Will & Emery LLP and is based in the Firm’s Boston office.  He focuses his practice on employee benefits, executive compensation and ERISA matters.  Joe’s experience includes ERISA fiduciary issues, benefits issues faced by non-profit entities, executive compensation and deferred compensation arrangements, equity award plan design, employment and severance arrangements, qualified plan work and employee benefits matters arising in mergers and acquisitions.

Joe received his J.D. from the University of Chicago Law School and his B.A., cum laude, from Williams College.

617-535-3854
Sophia Luby, McDermott Law Firm, Washington DC, Litigation Attorney
Associate

Sophia A. Luby focuses her practice on complex civil litigation.

While in law school, Sophia interned with The Honorable Anna Blackburne-Rigsby at the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, and with the United States Department of Justice, Civil Fraud Section. She was the senior notes editor for the Federal Circuit Bar Journal, a legal writing fellow and a dean’s fellow. She also received the Presidential Volunteer Service Award for her commitment to pro bono legal service. 

202-756-8758