October 26, 2020

Volume X, Number 300

Advertisement

October 23, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Recognition and Enforcement in Mexico of Foreign Reorganization Proceedings (Chapter 11)

COVID-19 has had a dramatic impact on the world economy with the virus affecting jobs and companies around the world in many ways, with imminent cash-flow shortfalls soon to occur throughout many sectors of the global economy.  This client alert analyzes how to utilize courts in Mexico to achieve recognition and enforcement of Chapter 11 proceedings (or other similar reorganization processes being conducted around the world) when the petitioner has assets or subsidiaries in Mexico. Undertaking certain proceedings in Mexico may allow financially-distressed companies to effectively enforce in Mexico the effects of the automatic stay pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 362 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Coe and other types of stay orders or injunctions obtained outside of Mexico in order to impede foreign or Mexican creditors from undertaking collection actions against assets and subsidiaries in Mexico to the detriment of the estate of the reorganization petitioner.  Many jurisdictions dictate that such reorganization processes cover all of the assets of the petitioner, wherever located; however, in many countries such as Mexico, in order to insure that assets in Mexico are validly included and protected, certain proceedings must first be undertaken before a Mexican court.  This is not unlike the Chapter 15 proceedings under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code to protect assets in the U.S. where owned by an entity undergoing a foreign restructuring proceeding.  

Article 279 of the Mexican Reorganizations Law contemplates the recognition in Mexico of a foreign chapter 11 or reorganization proceeding.  However, in order for such recognition to occur in Mexico, specific relief must be requested (the “Recognition Writ”) by the individual, court or party that has been appointed to manage the reorganization or to act on behalf of the reorganization proceeding or process (e.g., a trustee) (the “Appointed Representative”). 

In order to request such recognition, the Appointed Representative must submit the following documents to the Mexican court:

  • An authenticated resolution or certificate issued by the foreign bankruptcy court evidencing the existence of such foreign proceeding as well as the appointment of the Appointed Representative; 

  • In the absence of the aforementioned resolution or certificate, any other document that proves the existence of such foreign proceeding and the designation of the Appointed Representative; 

  • A declaration listing all of the foreign proceedings involving the petitioner of which the Appointed Representative has knowledge; and

  • A translation into Spanish of all of the documents that are included with the petition prepared by a certified translator authorized by the Mexican courts.

The Mexican Reorganizations Law allows for two different types of procedures in Mexico depending on whether or not the petitioner has a branch, subsidiary or a controlling interest in a Mexican company (collectively, the “Establishment”).

Recognition Procedure for Petitioners With an Establishment in Mexico

Upon the filing of the Recognition Writ, the Mexican court is required to analyze the admissibility of the writ, including compliance with certain formalities, to request the recognition and enforcement in Mexico of the foreign reorganization proceedings.  This includes a review of the qualifications and legitimacy of the Appointed Representative, as well as the authenticity of the documents provided and the circumstances surrounding any request for injunctive or temporary relief measures.

Once the Recognition Writ is duly-admitted, the Mexican court will undertake the following analysis of the Recognition Writ:

  • Order service of process on the Establishment requiring the Establishment to file an answer responding to the evidence and allegations contained in the Recognition Writ.  In addition, the Establishment is required to prepare a list naming the creditors of the Establishment, as well as any evidence to support the merits of the Establishment’s answer.

  • Request the assistance of the Mexican Federal Institute of Reorganization Specialists in order to appoint an examiner (the “Examiner”) who will attest, through the issuance of an Examiner’s Report, to the current financial condition of the Establishment considering the terms of the Recognition Writ and the answer provided by the Establishment. The designation of the Examiner and any assistants must be agreed to, and confirmed, by the Mexican court and the parties of interest in order to avoid any conflicts of interest.

  • In order to provide to the Mexican court the complete context of the case, the Appointed Representative is entitled to prepare a response to the allegations of the Establishment set forth in its answer to the Recognition Writ.

  • In the event of a request for injunctive or temporary relief by the Appointed Representative, the Court will analyze their admissibility during this procedural stage of the proceedings.

Once the Mexican court has completed the preceding review, the parties proceed to the review of the Examiner’s Report.  During this stage of the process, the Examiner visits the facilities of the Establishment and undertakes a review of the financial documents and information about the Establishment in order to prepare and issue the Examiner’s Report.

After the issuance of the Examiner’s Report, the Mexican court will require the parties to prepare and present their final arguments based upon which the Mexican court will issue a ruling whether or not to recognize and enforce the foreign reorganization process on the Establishment.  

Recognition Procedure for Petitioners That Do Not Have an Establishment in Mexico

In the event that the petitioner does not have an Establishment but does have assets in Mexico, the Appointed Representative that requests recognition of the foreign proceeding is required to designate an address so that a summons can be issued by the Mexican court.  In this type of ancillary proceeding, the only parties that appear before the Mexican court are the Appointed Representative and the petitioner.

In those situations where the petitioner does not have an Establishment in Mexico, there will therefore be no declaration or ruling from the Mexican court recognizing and enforcing the foreign Chapter 11 proceeding, nor a visit from an Examiner, due to the fact that the petitioner will not be able to demonstrate that it has an Establishment in Mexico.  Therefore, in principle, any creditors that wish to assert claims against these assets in Mexico will have to assert those claims in the foreign Chapter 11 proceeding.

© 2020 Foley & Lardner LLPNational Law Review, Volume X, Number 149
Advertisement

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS

Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Daniel Aranda Corporate & Trial Attorney Foley & Lardner Mexico City
Partner

Daniel Aranda is a bilingual, bicultural corporate and trial lawyer serving clients in the U.S., Mexican and international energy law, pipeline, banking and finance sectors. Daniel is also a member of Foley's Energy Industry, and Government Procurement Practice in Mexico City.

Daniel represents foreign and domestic clients with all aspects of their international energy law needs, including:

  • Representation before the Mexican energy authorities (CRE, CNH, Ministry of Energy, Pemex and CFE)
  • Mergers and acquisitions
  • Project development and...
52.55.5201.4518
Roberto Arena Reyes Retana, Foley Lardner Law Firm, Mexico, Insurance and Energy Law Attorney
Partner

Roberto Arena is a trusted advisor for businesses in the energy, insurance, electricity, financial, and oil and gas sectors, including many public companies with an interest in international tax planning and inbound and outbound international business transactions. He often handles sophisticated interpretation of treaties to avoid double taxation, large-scale mergers and acquisitions, real estate litigation, corporate organizations and reorganizations, and multi-jurisdictional litigation-related matters.

Roberto is the founding partner of the Latin American Network, a group of leading independent law firms representing global businesses concerned with privatization and the emerging free economies in the region. As a recognized international tax attorney, clients seek Roberto's wide-ranging insights and experience with general business needs, and the structuring and planning of tax-efficient structures. Particular strengths include:

  • Procurement law

  • Efficient tax treatment of shares and asset purchases

  • Federal and state tax and commercial litigation

  • Tax consequences of transactions and business operations

5255-5284-8542
Miguel Angel Hernandez Romo Valencia Litigation Attorney Foley & Lardner Mexico City, Mexico
Partner

Miguel Hernández Romo Valencia is a trilingual litigation attorney focusing his practice on complex litigation in civil, commercial, professional responsibility, family litigation, medical malpractice and insurance sectors. He also specializes in International arbitration and bankruptcy proceedings as well. Miguel serves as the Mexico City Office Chair for the firm's Litigation Department.

With a deep understanding of a wide variety of complex litigation issues, some of Miguel’s most recent matters include clients with private, non-profit and publicly-held companies in the medical,...

52.55.5284.8552
Charles E. Meacham Transactional Attorney Foley & Lardner Houston, TX
Partner

Charlie Meacham is a trilingual (Spanish and Portuguese) transactional lawyer born and raised in Caracas, Venezuela. After joining the former Dallas office of Gardere (now Foley) in 1988, Charlie moved to Mexico City to open the former Gardere (now Foley Arena) office in 1992 and was the resident partner in charge until 1996. He is now a member of Foley’s Houston office, where he focuses more broadly on cross-border projects and transactions in the United States, Mexico and throughout Latin America.

For 30 years, Mr. Meacham has focused on counseling clients on how to commence or...

713.276.5633
Holland N. O'Neil Corporate Restructuring Attorney Foley & Lardner Dallas, TX
Partner

Holland O’Neil is a skilled financial restructuring and reorganization partner, focusing primarily on corporate restructurings, with over 30 years of experience. She is well-regarded in the bankruptcy bar among judges and financial and other advisors, and she is described by clients in Chambers USA as “a top-notch lawyer,” receiving praise for her courtroom presence and negotiating skills.

Holland practices not only in Texas, but in jurisdictions across the United States. She assists companies with complex bankruptcies, restructurings and workouts, acquisitions of...

214.999.4961
Advertisement
Advertisement