January 18, 2022

Volume XII, Number 18

Advertisement
Advertisement

January 15, 2022

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Delaware Supreme Court Upholds Chancery Court Ruling that Applied Business Judgment Rule to Going Private Transaction with Controlling Stockholder

In Kahn v. M&F Worldwide Corp., the Delaware Supreme Court unanimously upheld the Chancery Court’s decision in In re MFW Shareholders Litigation. In that decision, the Chancery Court had granted summary judgment in favor of the board of directors of M&F Worldwide Corp. (M&F) in a suit brought by former stockholders of M&F challenging the going private acquisition of M&F by MacAndrews & Forbes Holdings Inc., the owner of 43.4 percent of M&F’s common stock. The Chancery Court held that a going private acquisition by a controlling stockholder that is conditioned, from the outset, on approval by both a properly empowered, independent committee, and an informed, uncoerced majority-of-the-minority vote would be reviewed under the business judgment standard of review, rather than the entire fairness standard of review. A summary of the Chancery Court’s decision in In re MFW Shareholders Litigation is included in the June 7, 2013 issue of Corporate & Financial Weekly Digest.

In upholding the Chancery Court’s decision, the Delaware Supreme Court held that the business judgment standard of review would apply to a going private acquisition by a controlling stockholder if, but only if, the following facts were established: (1) the controlling stockholder conditioned the transaction on the approval of both a special committee, and a majority-of-the-minority stockholders; (2) the special committee was independent; (3) the special committee was empowered to freely select its own advisors and to say no definitively; (4) the special committee acted with care; (5) the minority vote was informed; and (6) there was no coercion of the minority.

Notably, the Delaware Supreme Court left open the possibility for plaintiffs to question a special committee’s independence and its process for selling a target company. The Delaware Supreme Court indicated that if, following discovery, triable issues of fact remain about whether either of the procedural protections were established or were effective, the case would survive a motion for summary judgment and would be subject to entire fairness review at trial. In upholding the Chancery Court’s decision, the Delaware Supreme Court confirmed the Chancery Court’s findings that the plaintiffs had failed to raise any genuine issues of material fact as to whether the procedural protections had been established or were effective. Accordingly, the Chancery Court’s application of the business judgment standard of review at the summary judgment stage was found to be appropriate.

©2022 Katten Muchin Rosenman LLPNational Law Review, Volume IV, Number 80
Advertisement

About this Author

Mark Reyes Securities Lawyer Katten Muchin law firm Chicago office
Partner

Mark J. Reyes concentrates his practice in corporate and securities matters, including representing issuers and investors in public offerings and private placements of equity and debt securities and advising clients in complex corporate transactions such as mergers, acquisitions, private investments in public equity (PIPEs), private equity investments and joint ventures. He also counsels public companies on securities law compliance, disclosures and corporate governance matters.

Shown below is a...

312-902-5612
Mark D. Wood, corporate securities lawyer Katten Muchin Chicago Law firm
Partner

Mark D. Wood is head of Katten's Securities practice and concentrates in corporate and securities law. Mark represents public companies, issuers and investment banks in initial public offerings (IPOs) and other public offerings, private investment in public equity (PIPE) transactions, debt securities and other securities matters.

Mark also represents clients in complex corporate transactions, including tender offers, mergers, acquisitions, dispositions, going-private transactions, private equity investments, joint ventures and...

312-902-5493
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement