October 26, 2021

Volume XI, Number 299

Advertisement
Advertisement

October 26, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

October 25, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

Right to be forgotten controversially introduced into Maltese law

A recent press release from November 16, 2018 revealed that Malta’s Justice Minister introduced the right to be forgotten through a ministerial decree.  Since 2013, 86 out of 131 judgments have either been anonymized or removed from the courts’ public database.  The information came as a surprise to Malta’s legal community, as there had been no public announcement regarding the new right.  The exact date the new right was introduced has not been confirmed.

The discovery was made back in March 2018 by Times of Malta during research of a case in which judges had granted two law students permission to practice law, despite their criminal records.  The newspaper’s investigators were unable to retrieve the judgment of the original criminal sentence of one of the law students from the courts’ publicly available database.

The right to be forgotten has been applied in Malta despite the lack of written criteria.  Instead, Malta’s Justice Minister, who introduced the ministerial decree privately, refers all decisions on the right to be forgotten to Malta’s director general and data controller of the courts.  This has caused some controversy, as the director general is not part of the judiciary, but rather is a public servant who serves politicians.

According to the director general, Malta’s “established” criteria for applying the right to be forgotten with respect to court judgments are:

  • the reason for the request;
  • the time that elapsed since the date of judgment; and
  • the negative effects on other citizens.

Although there may no longer be access to the judgments deleted from the courts’ public database, the Justice Minister insists that lawyers are still able to access all judgments via the courts’ internal database.

© 2021 Covington & Burling LLPNational Law Review, Volume VIII, Number 330
Advertisement

About this Author

Repeatedly ranked as having one of the best privacy practices in the world, Covington combines exceptional substantive expertise with an unrivaled understanding of the IT industry, and of e-commerce and digital media business models in particular.  Our practice provides exceptional coverage of all of the substantive areas of privacy, including IT/technology, data security, financial privacy, health privacy, employment privacy, litigation and transactions.  One of our core strengths is the ability to advise clients on relevant privacy and data security rules worldwide,...

202.662.5519
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement