September 28, 2021

Volume XI, Number 271

Advertisement

September 27, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis
Advertisement

Texas Court Declines to Address Trespass Issue in Wastewater Migration Case

On February 6, 2015, the Texas Supreme Court issued a decision in Environmental Processing Systems, L.C. v. FPL Farming Ltd.  Although landowners and energy companies were hoping for a definitive answer on subsurface trespass, the Court sidestepped the issue.

FPL Farming Ltd. (“FPL”) owned surface and non-mineral subsurface rights to land, which it used for rice farming.  Environmental Processing Systems, L.C. (“EPS”) leased a small, adjacent property where it operated a wastewater disposal facility, pursuant to a permit from the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission (now known as Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (“TCEQ”)).  FPL sued for injunctive relief alleging, among other things, trespass, and alleged EPS trespassed when wastewater migrated onto its property.  The jury rendered a defense verdict finding in favor of EPS.

Through a series of appeals, this case came before the Court on the narrow issue of whether the jury instruction properly included lack of consent as an element of a trespass cause of action that a plaintiff must prove.  The Supreme Court found the jury charge provided the well-established definition of trespass, including lack of consent or authorization as an element of the cause of action.  The court reversed the Court of Appeals for the Ninth District and reinstated the trial court’s judgment that FPL take nothing.

Importantly, the Court expressly declined to rule on “whether Texas law recognizes a trespass cause of action for deep subsurface water migration.”  Therefore, we can expect additional lawsuits from future plaintiffs claiming neighboring wastewater injections constitute trespass.

© Steptoe & Johnson PLLC. All Rights Reserved.National Law Review, Volume V, Number 56
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

About this Author

Real estate lawyers work closely with clients to tailor the scope of services to the requirements of a particular project. The group’s objective is to provide first-class representation within a client’s budget. Clients appreciate the partnering relationship and team approach to the practice of law for which the firm is known. Group members consult with lawyers experienced in practice areas such as labor, tax, and environmental law to ensure that the client’s interests are being served.

304-598-8110
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement