December 1, 2021

Volume XI, Number 335


November 30, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

November 29, 2021

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

Play It Safe II: Employers At Risk If They Don’t Methodically Process Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Issues

Just a few days ago, Pete Tschanz posted here about a court decision where it seemed from the court’s decision that the employer moved to terminate an employee without really working through some employee health issues as required by the ADA. Just to echo that theme with another new decision, we offer the case of Spurling v. C&M Fine Pack, Inc., where the 7th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s summary decision in favor of the employer.

In short, the timeline in Spurling was at follows:

April 15, 2010 – Employee receives final warning for sleeping at work.

April 21 – Company received doctor’s note indicating that employee may have disability and needed further testing.

April 28 – Employee was terminated.

That timing will rarely work for an employer, regardless of various factors that may make a termination seem like the appropriate step.  (For example, why didn’t the employee here go to the doctor before the final warning when she had received other disciplines?) 

That doesn’t mean the employer cannot terminate an employee who cannot do the job.  Rather, it just means that, to position itself to successfully defend a lawsuit, the employer needs to expend a certain amount of effort communicating with the employee and/or medical practitioners to establish that fact.  Employers, it is very hard to win these cases if the timing looks in any way like a “gotcha.” I believe that jumping the gun on terminating employees with health issues may be the most common mistake that employers make. A small investment in your employment lawyer when you get that doctor’s note or other indication of a possible disability will save you time, money, and energy in the long run.

See Play It Safe I

See Play It Safe III

© 2021 BARNES & THORNBURG LLPNational Law Review, Volume IV, Number 21

About this Author

William A. Nolan Labor and Employment Law Attorney Barnes Thornburg Law Firm Columbus

William A. Nolan serves as the Managing Partner of Barnes & Thornburg LLP’s Columbus, Ohio, office, which he opened in 2009. He is a member of the firm’s Labor and Employment Law Department. Bill has extensive experience as a litigator, trial lawyer and counselor. His practice includes a broad range of issues that organizations face in our rapidly changing competitive, legal and workplace environments. In short, he works to help management structure organizations, practices and relationships to proactively minimize the business disruption of disputes, and to help clients prevail when...