September 21, 2020

Volume X, Number 265

September 21, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

September 18, 2020

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

SEC Proposes Significant Alterations for Financial Obligation Disclosures for Governmental Issuers and Certain Nonprofit Organizations

The Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") recently sent a clear message to participants in the municipal markets: it intends to require a greater level of disclosure, and more timely disclosure, regarding an obligated person's incurrence of debt and other financial obligations. The SEC's recent actions signal that it expects more detail about the terms of any material non-public transactions that could trigger events of default and cross-defaults for investors. Those terms include covenants and events of default. The SEC's Rule 15c2-12 (the "Rule") generally requires underwriters of municipal securities to obtain an agreement from "obligated persons" to provide, among other things, timely notice of certain events listed in the rule ("Listed Events"). "Obligated persons" include governmental issuers and nonprofit organizations that have borrowed proceeds of securities from a governmental issuer. On March 1, 2017, the SEC proposed to amend the Rule, the first significant revisions since 2010.1

The proposed amendment (the "Proposed 2017 Amendment") modifies the Listed Events to include two new items:

  • "the incurrence of a material financial obligation or any agreement to certain covenants, events of default, remedies, priority rights or other terms that could affect securities holders; and

  • defaults, events of acceleration, termination events or modifications of the terms or other similar events under the terms of the financial obligation of the obligated person that reflect financial difficulties."

Financial Obligations

The term "financial obligation" is broadly defined in the Proposed 2017 Amendment to mean "a (i) debt obligation, (ii) lease, (iii) guarantee, (iv) derivative instrument, or (v) monetary obligation resulting from a judicial, administrative, or arbitration proceeding. The term financial obligation shall not include municipal securities as to which a final official statement has been provided to the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board consistent with this rule."

Implications of the Proposed 2017 Amendment

If the SEC adopts the Proposed 2017 Amendment, obligated persons will need to consider what level of detail is appropriate to describe their financial obligations, as well as the related covenants and events of default. Historically, many obligated persons have not provided detailed summaries of covenants and events of default in non-public transactions with lenders and swap providers, since those provisions can be re-negotiated by the parties to the arrangement, and the obligated person's bondholders have no rights with respect to those covenants and/or events of default.

In the SEC's commentary that accompanies the Proposed 2017 Amendment, the SEC noted its belief that "the proposed amendments would facilitate investors' and other market participants' access to important information in a timely manner and help to enhance transparency in the municipal securities market and improve investor protection."

The SEC is particularly concerned that investors may not have access or timely access to disclosure about non-public transactions, which could lead to investors making investment decisions without the ability to understand the obligated person's total debt obligations, as well as any cross-default risk if those non-public transactions include more restrictive covenants than those included in the publicly offered debt.

The SEC is also concerned that investors do not have access or timely access to disclosures regarding the occurrence of events that reflect financial difficulties (for example, defaults, events of acceleration, termination event, modifications of terms or other similar events).

The SEC's actions here are consistent with concerns that it raised in 2012 with its Report on the Municipal Securities Market (the "2012 Municipal Report").2 In that 2012 Municipal Report, the SEC recommended that the Rule be amended to mandate more specific types of secondary market disclosure, including disclosure relating to new indebtedness (whether or not such debt is subject to the Rule and whether or not arising as a result of a municipal securities issuance).3

Next Steps

The SEC is seeking public comment on the Proposed 2017 Amendment for a period of sixty days from the date of publication (March 1, 2017). While the SEC may modify certain portions of the Proposed 2017 Amendment in response to these public comments, it is clear that the SEC intends to take some action to require a greater level of disclosure, and more timely disclosure, regarding an obligated person's incurrence of debt and other financial obligations.


1Under the 2010 revisions, the SEC modified and expanded the "listed events" that must be reported by an obligated person, and required that the obligated person provide notice of any such event within 10 business days of its occurrence.

2Securities and Exchange Commission, Report on the Municipal Securities Market (July 31, 2012).

3Id. at 139-40.

© Polsinelli PC, Polsinelli LLP in CaliforniaNational Law Review, Volume VII, Number 80

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Charles D. Katz, Polsinelli, tax-exempt financing transactions Lawyer
Shareholder

Chuck Katz has more than 27 years of experience in the public finance field. He has served as bond, underwriter, tax, issuer or borrower counsel in connection with tax-exempt financing transactions in more than 25 states, including Illinois, Wisconsin, New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maine, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Arizona, California, Washington, Delaware, Connecticut and West Virginia, as well as Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. A significant part of his practice focuses on the tax component of public finance transactions...

312-463-6376
Lisa Greer Quateman, Polsinelli, capital markets transactions lawyer, regulatory matters attorney
Principal

Clients and prospective clients seek out Lisa Quateman for her experience and capabilities in capital markets transactions and regulatory matters. Lisa’s concise and in-depth analysis of clients’ matters linked with her commitment to high quality and prompt service have earned her a loyal clientele.

Lisa served as the founding Managing Partner for Polsinelli’s Los Angeles office from its inception in 2011 through January 2016. During that period of time the office grew five-fold and established a strong presence in the local community.

A trusted advisor to in-house counsel and business executives, Lisa has attracted public and private companies, management teams, entrepreneurs, property owners, nonprofit organizations, financial institutions, utilities, and government entities. As a capital markets attorney with extensive experience, Lisa has developed specialized expertise in the areas of public government assisted finance, representing parties on all sides of these transactions.

310-203-5303
Timothy J. Reimers, Polsinelli, acquisitions Lawyer, large real estate portfolios attorney
Principal

Whether closing an acquisition of large real estate portfolios, financing sophisticated projects or providing legal counsel on day-to-day operations, Tim Reimers strives to provide clients with the highest possible level of legal advice. Clients rely on the focused service and zealous representation Tim brings to project, infrastructure and health care finance. As a team leader in Polsinelli’s finance and real estate practices, he helps clients acquire, develop and finance their operations, real estate and other capital resources. Tim’s experience and reputation is built...

310-203-5316
Jessica Jacob Zaiger, Polsinelli, taxable financing transactions lawyer, compliance matters attorney
Shareholder

Jessica Zaiger is committed to diligently representing health care and other nonprofit organizations and assisting them with their financing needs. From complex tax-exempt and taxable financing transactions to routine compliance matters, Jessica is poised to provide guidance and advice. She joined Polsinelli because of its commitment to participants in the health care and nonprofit sectors, as well as its strong relationship with health care and nonprofit organizations across the nation. Jessica is dedicated to contributing to these relationships by providing valuable...

816-572-4419
Janet E. Zeigler, Polsinelli, health care, long-term care lawyer,  educational facilities attorney
Shareholder

Having acted as counsel on more than 200 issues totaling over $25 billion, Janet Zeigler understands the intricacies associated with nonprofit finance. Most of her 22 years of experience have been focused on tax-exempt financing transactions for 501(c)(3) organizations, including health care, long-term care, cultural, and educational facilities. Janet also counsels clients in connection with the negotiation of bank credit agreements, and provides advice for post-issuance compliance with federal securities laws and federal tax laws relating to tax exempt bonds, including...

312-873-3679