December 7, 2019

December 06, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

December 05, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

December 04, 2019

Subscribe to Latest Legal News and Analysis

NYCCHR Issues Guidance on Discrimination Based on Immigration Status and National Origin

The New York City Commission on Human Rights (“the Commission”) published a legal enforcement guidance (“Guidance”) clarifying its standards with respect to discrimination based on actual or perceived immigration status and national origin. The Guidance applies to employers, housing providers, and providers of public accommodations.

As the Guidance explains, “[d]iscrimination based on immigration status often overlaps with discrimination based on national origin and/or religion.” Under the New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”), employers with four or more employees are prohibited from discriminating on any of these bases against job applicants, employees, interns and independent contractors.

Much of the focus of the new Guidance is on discriminatory conduct based on citizenship status and “work authorization” status. In this regard, the Guidance reiterates the following mandates:

  • Employers may not discriminate among work-authorized individuals, including citizens, permanent residents, refugees, asylees, and those granted lawful temporary status, unless required or explicitly permitted by law.

  • Job application and interview questions related to work authorization must be applied uniformly to all applicants, and not selectively, based on the actual or perceived immigration status or national origin of the applicant.

  • If an employer employs workers who are unauthorized to work, those workers may not be treated less favorably on the basis of their immigration status.

  • Employers may not engage in “document abuse” by demanding documents from a job applicant or worker beyond those required to establish work authorization under federal law, including green cards and birth certificates. Employers must accept any document from the “List of Acceptable Documents” established by federal law on a Form I-9.

  • Except in limited, specified circumstances, employers may not re-verify an employee’s work authorization.

  • An employer may not take any adverse action against an applicant or worker based on a No-Match Letter from the Social Security Administration.

  • Employers may refuse Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”) access to non-public facing areas of their workplace if the agents do not produce a warrant signed by a judge.

  • An employer may not threaten workers with ICE involvement to harass, intimidate, or retaliate against employees.

  • The guidance instructs against the use of such terms as “illegal alien” and “illegals,” and reiterates that the NYCHRL prohibits the use of such terms to demean or offend people in the workplace.

The Guidance provides examples of specific kinds of actions that violate the NYCHRL including the following:

  • Granting workers different break arrangements based on their immigration or work authorization status.

  • Threatening to contact ICE if a worker attends a necessary medical appointment.

  • Refusing to accept a Social Security card and demanding a birth certificate from a job applicant because the applicant has an accent.

  • Prohibiting hotel housekeepers from speaking Spanish while cleaning because it might make guests uncomfortable.

  • Using a No-Match letter as an excuse to terminate an otherwise qualified worker.

  • Providing Polish workers (or workers of any specific nationality) first priority in scheduling to the disadvantage of its U.S. citizen workers (or workers of another nationality).

The Guidance further instructs that once an employer hires a worker who is unauthorized to work or undocumented, that worker is covered by the NYCHRL and may file a claim of discrimination with the New York City Commission on Human Rights or a lawsuit.

Finally, employers should be aware that a new state law, effective August 15, 2019 and applicable to all New York employers as of February 8, 2020, prohibits employers from threatening, penalizing, or otherwise discriminating or retaliating against an immigrant employee, including threatening to report that person or a member of his or her family to U.S. immigration authorities.

The recent focus by both the state and the city on discrimination based on immigration status suggests that employers should anticipate increased scrutiny and enforcement concerning this issue.

©2019 Epstein Becker & Green, P.C. All rights reserved.

TRENDING LEGAL ANALYSIS


About this Author

Susan Gross Sholinsky, Labor Employment Attorney, Epstein Becker Green Law Firm
Member of the Firm

SUSAN GROSS SHOLINSKY is a Member of the Firm in the Labor and Employment practice, in the New York office of Epstein Becker Green. She counsels clients on a variety of matters, in a practical and straightforward manner, with an eye toward reducing the possibility of employment-related claims. In 2013, Ms. Sholinsky was named to theNew York Metro Rising Stars list in the area of Employment & Labor.

212-351-4789
Nancy Gunzenhauser, Labor Employment Attorney, Epstein Becker Law Firm
Associate

NANCY L. GUNZENHAUSER is an Associate in the Labor and Employment practice, in the New York office of Epstein Becker Green.

Ms. Gunzenhauser:

  • Counsels clients on compliance with EEO laws, the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Family and Medical Leave Act, worker classification issues, and other federal, state, and local statutes governing the workplace
  • Advises employers in all facets of the employment relationship, from pre-employment considerations and hiring to terminations and post-employment restrictions
  • Prepares employment, consulting, and separation agreements
  • Audits employers’ employment policies, procedures, and handbooks to ensure compliance with applicable laws and best practices
  • Conducts workplace training seminars for employees, managers, and human resources personnel
  • Assists in defending clients in labor and employment-related litigation in a broad array of matters, such as discrimination, harassment, retaliation, breach of contract, and wage and hour disputes
212-351-3758
Corben J. Green Associate ADA and Public Accommodations  Employment Training, Practices, and Procedures  Wage and Hour
Associate

CORBEN J. GREEN is an Associate in the Employment, Labor & Workforce Management practice, in the New York office of Epstein Becker Green. He will be focusing his practice on disability laws, wage and hour issues, and employment training, practices, and procedures.

Mr. Green received his Juris Doctor from Columbia Law School, where he was a Harlan Fiske Stone Scholar and a Notes Editor of the Columbia Journal of Race and Law. He also participated in the school’s Lawyering in the Digital Age Clinic and Domestic Violence Project and...

212-351-4583